Bay Village Real Estate 2014

Sales Listing

BAY VILLAGE
Sales From: 2014-01-01 To 2014-01-31

Certified Year: 2013

Parcel Year: 2014

font size=3>Run Date: 2/3/2014

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

201-12-016 5100 R 31402 MANCHESTER LN 01/03/14 0 .000 Y 1
MCCRYSTAL JAMES L. JR. QUIT CLAIM BURKE JAMES F., TRUSTEE 312,100
627096 Lnd: 73,700 Bld: 312,100 Tot: 385,800
MCCRYSTAL JAMES L. JR. 31402 MANCHESTER LN BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MCCRYSTAL JAMES L. JR. 31402 MANCHESTER LN BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-12-042 5100 R 31037 NARRAGANSETT LN 01/22/14 0 .000 Y 1
THOMPSON PHILIP R AFFIDAVIT THOMPSON PHILIP R 190,300
629042 Lnd: 77,200 Bld: 190,300 Tot: 267,500
PHILIP THOMPSON 31037 NARRAGANSETT LN BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
PHILIP THOMPSON 22050 MASTICK RD CLEVELAND, OH 44126

201-13-061 5100 R 31115 NANTUCKET ROW 01/23/14 395,000 .720 Y 1
WARD, PETER P. & WARD, DARLENE C. WARRANTY D HOWDER, STEVE & BETH 215,300
629354 296631 Lnd: 69,800 Bld: 215,300 Tot: 285,100
WARD, PETER P. 31115 NANTUCKET ROW BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
WARD, PETER P. 31115 NANTUCKET ROW BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-14-036 5100 R 31416 NANTUCKET ROW 01/17/14 0 .000 Y 1
DOHENY, PATRICIA A. EXECUTORS DOHENY, PATRICIA A. TRUSTEE 309,300
628597 Lnd: 69,500 Bld: 309,300 Tot: 378,800
DOHENY, JOHN T (AKA) JOHN T III (T 31416 NANTUCKET ROW BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DOHENY, JOHN T (AKA) JOHN T III (T 31416 NANTUCKET ROW BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 1

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

201-14-036 5100 R 31416 NANTUCKET ROW 01/22/14 0 .000 Y 1
DOHENY, JOHN T & JOHN T III WARRANTY D DOHENY, PATRICIA A. 309,300
629133 Lnd: 69,500 Bld: 309,300 Tot: 378,800
DOHENY, JOHN T (AKA) JOHN T III (T 31416 NANTUCKET ROW BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DOHENY, JOHN T (AKA) JOHN T III (T 31416 NANTUCKET ROW BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-14-036 5100 R 31416 NANTUCKET ROW 01/23/14 0 .000 Y 1
DOHENY, JOHN T (AKA) JOHN T III (T WARRANTY D DOHENY, JOHN T & JOHN T III 309,300
629338 Lnd: 69,500 Bld: 309,300 Tot: 378,800
DOHENY, JOHN T (AKA) JOHN T III (T 31416 NANTUCKET ROW BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DOHENY, JOHN T (AKA) JOHN T III (T 31416 NANTUCKET ROW BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-16-025 5100 R 31108 CARLTON DR 01/22/14 0 .000 Y 1
SHIGAR PARTNER, LLC WARRANTY D SHIRLEY, BART 107,400
629163 Lnd: 26,800 Bld: 107,400 Tot: 134,200
SHIGAR PARTNER, LLC 31108 CARLTON DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SHIGAR PARTNER, LLC 1660 W2ND ST CLEVELAND, OH 44113

201-21-024 5100 R 00442 BATES DR 01/27/14 0 .000 Y 1
LOVELAND, LINDA LEE ET AL AFFIDAVIT MILLER, NANCY D. 137,800
629717 Lnd: 45,800 Bld: 137,800 Tot: 183,600
LOVELAND, LINDA LEE ET AL 00442 BATES DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
LOVELAND, LINDA LEE ET AL 442 BATES DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

tr>

202-03-003 5000 R LAKE RD 01/16/14 184,000 .050 Y 2
MURTHA MICHAEL A. WARRANTY D LEOPOLD, DONALD E. 0
628421 296298 Lnd: 8,500 Bld: 0 Tot: 8,500
MURTHA MICHAEL A. LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MURTHA MICHAEL A. 295 GLEN PARK DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-03-021 5000 R 29297 LAKE RD 01/16/14 184,000 .240 Y 2
MURTHA MICHAEL A. WARRANTY D LEOPOLD, DONALD E. 0
628421 296298 Lnd: 43,500 Bld: 0 Tot: 43,500
MURTHA MICHAEL A. 29297 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MURTHA MICHAEL A. 29297 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 2

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

202-19-007 5100 R 30210 ASHTON LN 01/23/14 170,000 1.240 Y 1
DAVISON, ROBERT J. & ELIZABETH J. SURVIVORSH WILDNER, SYLVIA 169,800
629352 296629 Lnd: 41,100 Bld: 169,800 Tot: 210,900
DAVISON, ROBERT J. 30210 ASHTON LN BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DAVISON, ROBERT J. 30210 ASHTON LN BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-24-012 5100 R 29485 WOLF RD 01/29/14 375,000 .510 Y 1
GLYNIAS, MANUEL P WARRANTY D LOVASH, LESLIE E. 109,500
629975 296917 Lnd: 80,500 Bld: 109,500 Tot: 190,000
MANUEL P GLYNIAS 29485 WOLF RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MANUEL P GLYNIAS 29404 OSBORN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-28-021 5100 R 28326 WEST OAKLAND RD 01/08/14 0 .000 Y 1
FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORAT SHERIFFS D ARMANINI PATRICIA M 148,200
627280 Lnd: 46,800 Bld: 148,200 Tot: 195,000
FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORAT 28326 WEST OAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORAT 3232 NEWMARK DR MIAMISBURG, OH 45342

202-33-012 5100 R 29401 OSBORN RD 01/29/14 140,000 1.230 Y 1
US BANK TRUST NA SHERIFFS D WAGNER, MARK 130,400
629855 296845 Lnd: 42,300 Bld: 130,400 Tot: 172,700
US BANK TRUST NA 29401 OSBORN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
US BANK TRUST NA 16745 WBERNARDO DR 300 SAN DIEGO, CA 92127

202-33-016 5100 R 29415 OSBORN RD 01/15/14 190,000 .860 Y 1
MURRAY, BRUCE C. & DANNA L. SURVIVORSH PARAS, CATHERINE ANNE TRUSTEE 120,400
628280 296243 Lnd: 42,300 Bld: 120,400 Tot: 162,700
MURRAY, BRUCE C. 29415 OSBORN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MURRAY, BRUCE C. 29415 OSBORN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-34-005 5100 R 00571 BASSETT RD 01/08/14 0 .000 Y 1
HODGE, NEIL E & BOTHEL , DEBRA J SURVIVORSHfont> HODGE NEIL E 157,400
627344 Lnd: 37,900 Bld: 157,400 Tot: 195,300
HODGE, NEIL E 00571 BASSETT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
HODGE, NEIL E 571 BASSETT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 3

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

202-36-001 5100 R 00597 BASSETT RD 01/03/14 0 .000 Y 1
FANTER, FREDERICK W. & KARLA R. TRU QUIT CLAIM FANTER, FRED W. 59,000
627015 Lnd: 32,000 Bld: 59,000 Tot: 91,000
FANTER, FREDERICK W. 00597 BASSETT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
FANTER, FREDERICK W. 597 BASSETT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-36-002 5100 R 00603 BASSETT RD 01/30/14 0 .000 Y 1
tr>

LOIACONO, DEBORAH S. CHANGE OF ROSSMAN, DEBORAH 133,600
630105 Lnd: 31,200 Bld: 133,600 Tot: 164,800
LOIACONO, DEBORAH S. 00603 BASSETT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
LOIACONO, DEBORAH S. 603 BASSETT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-36-002 5100 R 00603 BASSETT RD 01/30/14 0 .000 Y 1
LOIACONO, DEBORAH S. & LOIACONO, FR QUIT CLAIM LOIACONO, DEBORAH S. 133,600
630107 Lnd: 31,200 Bld: 133,600 Tot: 164,800
LOIACONO, DEBORAH S. 00603 BASSETT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
LOIACONO, DEBORAH S. 603 BASSETT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-03-004 5100 R 28023 WOLF RD 01/14/14 145,000 .910 Y 1
FILM, SANDRA J. WARRANTY D FEENEY, MEGAN A. 100,800
628136 font size=2>296181 Lnd: 30,900 Bld: 100,800 Tot: 131,700
FILM, SANDRA J. 28023 WOLF RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
FILM, SANDRA J. 28023 WOLF RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-07-066 5100 R 27913 REXFORD AVE 01/23/14 129,000 1.000 Y 1
TROLIO, DIANA & EHRMAN, JAKE SURVIVORSH PENCE, RUBY JANE TRUSTEE 95,600
629377 296649 Lnd: 33,500 Bld: 95,600 Tot: 129,100
TROLIO, DIANA 27913 REXFORD AVE BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
TROLIO, DIANA 27913 REXFORD AVE BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-16-021 5100 R 27027 WOLF RD 01/29/14 0 .000 Y 1
HOUSEHOLDER, TIMOTHY E. BEVERLY R SURVIVORSH HOUSEHOLDER, TIMOTHY E. 145,400
629885 Lnd: 35,600 Bld: 145,400 Tot: 181,000
HOUSEHOLDER, TIMOTHY E. BEVERLY R 27027 WOLF RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
HOUSEHOLDER, TIMOTHY E. BEVERLY R 27027 WOLF RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 4

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

203-17-017 5100 R 26818 WOLF RD 01/16/14 150,000 1.290 Y 1
SEDLAK, THOMAS & PATRICIA SURVIVORSH MORISKY, BARBARA LOUISE 162,900
628410 296291 Lnd: 30,300 Bld: 162,900 Tot: 193,200
SEDLAK, THOMAS 26818 WOLF RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SEDLAK, THOMAS 26818 WOLF RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

p>

203-23-036 5100 R 26911 KNICKERBOCKER RD 01/23/14 55,000 2.310 Y 1
US BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION AS TRU SHERIFFS D CARROLL, GERALD M. (SINGLE) 91,900
629279 296606 Lnd: 35,400 Bld: 91,900 Tot: 127,300
US BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION AS TRU 26911 KNICKERBOCKER RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
US BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION AS TRU 1100 VIRGINIA DR FORT WASHINGTON, PA 19034

203-30-037 5100 R 00609 PARKSIDE DR 01/16/14 0 .000 Y 1
DOBRZANSKI, MICHAEL T. QUIT CLAIM DOBRZANSKI, MICHAEL T. 105,900
628335 Lnd: 26,800 Bld: 105,900 Tot: 132,700
MICHAEL T DOBRZANSKI 00609 PARKSIDE DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MICHAEL T DOBRZANSKI 609 PARKSIDE DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-30-064 5100 R 00622 HUNTMERE RD 01/29/14 145,000 .960 Y 1
GARBA JR , BRUCE A & WHITAKER, LIN LIMITED WA PITFA PROPERTIES, LLC 108,200
629864 296854 Lnd: 31,200 Bld: 108,200 Tot: 139,400
GARBA JR , BRUCE A & WHITAKER, LIN 00622 HUNTMERE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
GARBA JR , BRUCE A & WHITAKER, LIN 7007 BROADWAY CLEVELAND, OH 44105

203-30-068 5100 R 25819 EATON WAY WAY 01/29/14 0 .000 Y 1
SECRETARY OF HOUSING & URBAN DEVELO WARRANTY D MIDFIRST BANK 66,500
629925 Lnd: 29,300 Bld: 66,500 Tot: 95,800
SECRETARY OF HOUSING & URBAN DEVELO 25819 EATON WAY WAY BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SECRETARY OF HOUSING & URBAN DEVELO 451 7TH ST WASHINGTON, DC 20410

203-30-076 5100 R 00589 HUNTMERE RD 01/15/14 146,500 .840 Y 1
SAMMON, JOHN R. IV WARRANTY D COSTANTINO, KATHY A. 92,400
628240 296218 Lnd: 30,600 Bld: 92,400 Tot: 123,000
SAMMON, JOHN R. IV 00589 HUNTMERE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SAMMON, JOHN R. IV 589 HUNTMERE DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 5

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

203-31-006 5100 R 00529 KENILWORTH RD 01/23/14 168,000 .830 Y 1
SCANLAN, MICHAEL B. & JULIE K. SURVIVORSH HARMAN, GORDON L., II, & SUSAN CO- 112,300
629330 296619 Lnd: 27,000 Bld: 112,300 Tot: 139,300
SCANLAN, MICHAEL B. 00529 KENILWORTH RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SCANLAN, MICHAEL B. 529 KENILWORTH RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-31-030 5100 R 00524 PARKSIDE DR 01/30/14 0 .000 Y 1
QUINN, THOMAS H AFFIDAVIT QUINN THOMAS H 92,700
630070 Lnd: 27,000 Bld: 92,700 Tot: 119,700
QUINN, THOMAS H 00524 PARKSIDE DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
QUINN, THOMAS H 524 PARKSIDE DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-31-063 5100 R 00502 HUNTMERE RD 01/30/14 134,000 .970 Y 1
HUBBARD, WILLIAM E. & HUBBARD, MARY/font> SURVIVORSH RONSENHAUS, JAMES N. & CAROLE A. 102,100
630144 296971 Lnd: 27,800 Bld: 102,100 Tot: 129,900
HUBBARD, WILLIAM E. 00502 HUNTMERE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
HUBBARD, WILLIAM E. 502 HUNTMERE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-31-082 5100 R 00533 HUNTMERE RD 01/24/14 0 .000 Y 1
NAPIER, LARAINE E QUIT CLAIM KLING LAVERNE M 101,600
629506 Lnd: 30,700 Bld: 101,600 Tot: 132,300
NAPIER, LARAINE E 00533 HUNTMERE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
NAPIER, LARAINE E 533 HUNTMERE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-07-008 5100 R 00452 FORESTVIEW RD 01/24/14 675,000 .790 Y 1
KROEN, COLLIN WARRANTY D LUFKIN, DOUGLAS A. & KATHLEEN T. 477,100
629496 296687 Lnd: 58,800 Bld: 477,100 Tot: 535,900
KROEN, COLLIN 00452 FORESTVIEW RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
KROEN, COLLIN 452 FORESTVIEW RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-10-020 5100 R 24700 OAKLAND RD 01/31/14 0 .000 Y 1
WILLIAMS, RICHARD B. & TAKAHASHI, J SURVIVORSH WILLIAMS, RICHARD B. 161,900
630326 Lnd: 28,000 Bld: 161,900 Tot: 189,900
WILLIAMS, RICHARD B. 24700 OAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
WILLIAMS, RICHARD B. 24700 EOAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 6

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

204-14-010 5000 R 24818 LAKE RD 01/16/14 0 .000 Y 1
SMITH, MICHAEL J QUIT CLAIM GREEN LEAF PROPERTIES, LLC 0
628390 Lnd: 34,100 Bld: 0 Tot: 34,100
MICHAEL J SMITH 24818 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MICHAEL J SMITH 14775 PEARL RD STRONGSVILLE, OH 44136

204-15-013 5100 R 24321 EAST OAKLAND RD 01/27/14 165,000 .810 Y 1
MULL, ERIC P. WARRANTY D VONDUHN, PATRICIA 102,600
629791 296818 Lnd: 31,500 Bld: 102,600 Tot: 134,100
MULL, ERIC P. 24321 EAST OAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MULL, ERIC P. 24321 E OAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-15-014 5100 R 24325 OAKLAND RD 01/10/14 117,500 1.600 Y 1
FRANTZ, KYLE & FRANTZ, MARGARET SURVIVORSH HERZBERGER III, RAYMOND G.(VENDOR) 156,500
627711 295976 Lnd: 31,900 Bld: 156,500 Tot: 188,400
FRANTZ, KYLE 24325 OAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
FRANTZ, KYLE 24325 OAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-17-044 5100 R 24509 LAKE RD 01/17/14 186,000 .900 Y 1
SPOTZ, DANIEL AND ELIZABETH SURVIVORSH ADKINS HOLLY DEE 120,600
628506 296312 Lnd: 46,700 Bld: 120,600 Tot: 167,300
SPOTZ, DANIEL AND ELIZABETH 24509 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SPOTZ, DANIEL AND ELIZABETH 24509 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-21-053 5100 R 24214 BRUCE RD 01/15/14 0 .000 Y 1
GORBOSKE, JOHN P QUIT CLAIM GORBOSKE, JOHN 93,000
628289 Lnd: 37,100 Bld: 93,000 Tot: 130,100
GORBOSKE, JOHN P 24214 BRUCE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
GORBOSKE, JOHN P 24214 BRUCE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-26-070 4520 C 00585 CLAGUE RD 01/16/14 0 .000 Y 1
HADNEY, ETHEL ANN ET AL PROBATE CO HADNEY, ETHEL ANN 31,900
628328 Lnd: 118,100 Bld: 31,900 Tot: 150,000
HADNEY, ETHEL ANN ET AL 00585 CLAGUE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
HADNEY, ETHEL ANN ET AL 585 CLAGUE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Total Number of Parcels: 40 Total Sales -6.00

Sales File Validation

Page 7

Sales Listing

BAY VILLAGE
Sales From: 2014-02-01 To 2014-02-28

Certified Year: 2013

Parcel Year: 2014

font size=3>Run Date: 3/3/2014

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

201-02-058 5100 R 00065 HUNTINGTON WOODS PKWY 02/06/14 0 .000 Y 1
RODMAN,JOHN D – SUC – TRUSTEE AFFIDAVIT RODMAN, RICHARD W. TRUSTEE 186,500
631118 Lnd: 42,100 Bld: 186,500 Tot: 228,600
ZYCHOWSKI, MICHAEL J AND ELIZABETH 00065 HUNTINGTON WOODS PKWY BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
ZYCHOWSKI, MICHAEL J AND ELIZABETH 65 HUNTINGTON WOODS PKWY BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-02-058 5100 R 00065 HUNTINGTON WOODS PKWY 02/06/14 240,000 .950 Y 1
ZYCHOWSKI, MICHAEL J AND ELIZABETH SURVIVORSH RODMAN,JOHN D – SUC – TRUSTEE 186,500
631123 297394 Lnd: 42,100 Bld: 186,500 Tot: 228,600
ZYCHOWSKI, MICHAEL J AND ELIZABETH 00065 HUNTINGTON WOODS PKWY BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
ZYCHOWSKI, MICHAEL J AND ELIZABETH 65 HUNTINGTON WOODS PKWY BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-04-010 5100 R 30734 LAKE RD 02/18/14 410,000 1.770 Y 1
HSBC BANK USA NATIONAL ASSOCIATION SHERIFFS D MICHAEL, MICHELLE E. TRUSTEE 588,400

td width=10%>

632313 297890 Lnd: 137,600 Bld: 588,400 Tot: 726,000
HSBC BANK USA NATIONAL ASSOCIATION 30734 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
HSBC BANK USA NATIONAL ASSOCIATION 3476 STATEVIEW BLVD FORT MILL, SC 29715

201-12-042 5100 R 31037 NARRAGANSETT LN 02/03/14 264,000 1.010 Y 1
SMITH, WILL AND CHERI A FIDUCIARY THOMPSON PHILIP R 190,300
630672 297226 Lnd: 77,200 Bld: 190,300 Tot: 267,500
SMITH, WILL AND CHERI A 31037 NARRAGANSETT LN BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SMITH, WILL AND CHERI A 31037 NARRAGANSETT LN BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 1

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

201-12-059 5100 R 31213 MANCHESTER LN 02/20/14 0 .000 Y 1

td width=15%>203,700

HOULAS, MARC THOMAS & HOULAS, KATEL WARRANTY D HOULAS, MARC THOMAS & HOULAS, KATEL
632727 Lnd: 75,000 Bld: 203,700 Tot: 278,700
HOULAS, MARC THOMAS 31213 MANCHESTER LN BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
HOULAS, MARC THOMAS 31213 MANCHESTER LN BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-25-017 5100 R 00530 KIMERLY DR 02/21/14 295,000 .990 Y 1
RYAN THOMAS P & JENNIFER WARRANTY D SHREFFLER, KURT R. 243,500
633071 298165 Lnd: 49,500 Bld: 243,500 Tot: 293,000
RYAN THOMAS P 00530 KIMERLY DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
RYAN THOMAS P 530 KIMERLY DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140/font>

202-01-006 5100 R 29708 LAKE RD 02/07/14 0 .000 Y 1
HARDIN, KATHIE M. TRUSTEE QUIT CLAIM HARDIN, KATHIE M. 867,400
631338 Lnd: 260,900 Bld: 867,400 Tot: 1,128,300td>
HARDIN, KATHIE M. TRUSTEE 29708 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
HARDIN, KATHIE M. TRUSTEE 29708 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-01-023 5100 R 00299 BASSETT RD 02/28/14 90,000 1.510 Y 1
THIRD FEDERAL SAVINGS AND LOAN ASSO SHERIFFS D DEWEES, MALCOLM 103,000
634064 298546 Lnd: 32,700 Bld: 103,000 Tot: 135,700
THIRD FEDERAL SAVINGS AND LOAN ASSO 00299 BASSETT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
THIRD FEDERAL SAVINGS AND LOAN ASSO 7007 BROADWAY AVE CLEVELAND, OH 44105

202-10-033 5100 R 29113 FOOTE RD 02/04/14 0 .000 Y 1
POWERS, TRACY E.& PETE W SURVIVORSH POWERS, TRACY E. TRUSTEE 108,100
630694 Lnd: 40,100 Bld: 108,100 Tot: 148,200
POWERS, TRACY E. 29113 FOOTE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
POWERS, TRACY E. 29113 FOOTE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-10-033 5100 R 29113 FOOTE RD 02/04/14 0 .000 Y 1
POWERS, TRACY E.& PETE W CO TRUST QUIT CLAIM POWERS, TRACY E.& PETE W 108,100
630695 Lnd: 40,100 Bld: 108,100 Tot: 148,200
POWERS, TRACY E. 29113 FOOTE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
POWERS, TRACY E. 29113 FOOTE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 2

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

202-29-002 5100 R 28115 OSBORN RD 02/21/14 210,000 1.080 Y 1
DUDAS, JOHN AND APRYL SURVIVORSH DOMY, LLC 179,700
633045 298144 Lnd: 46,400 Bld: 179,700 Tot: 226,100
DUDAS, JOHN AND APRYL 28115 OSBORN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DUDAS, JOHN AND APRYL 28115 OSBORN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-34-016 5100 R 29711 OSBORN RD 02/14/14 0 .000 Y 1
GAYTON DAVID E & CHERYL A – CO TRU WARRANTY D GAYTON, DAVID E 149,100
632243 Lnd: 44,000 Bld: 149,100 Tot: 193,100
GAYTON DAVID E 29711 OSBORN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
GAYTON DAVID E 29711 OSBORN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-05-015 5100 R 27888 LINCOLN RD 02/04/14 0 .000 Y 1
ATLAGOVICH, CHARLES QUIT CLAIM ATLAGOVICH, CHARLES 64,700
630747 Lnd: 33,500 Bld: 64,700 Tot: 98,200
CHARLES ATLAGOVICH 27888 LINCOLN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
CHARLES ATLAGOVICH 15911 TRINTER RD VERMILLION, OH 44089

203-06-011 5100 R 00536 CAHOON RD 02/24/14 115,000 1.290 Y 1
RIFE, DANIEL L & RIFE, THERESE A. SURVIVORSH HLUSKO, KATHRYN LOUISE (TRS) 111,700
633194 298206 Lnd: 37,100 Bld: 111,700 Tot: 148,800
RIFE, DANIEL L 00536 CAHOON RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
RIFE, DANIEL L 536 CAHOON RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-18-073 5100 R 26600 JEFFERSON CT 02/19/14 0 .000 Y 1
MACK, THOMAS W. & MOLLY S. CO-TRUS FIDUCIARY MACK, THOMAS W. & MOLLY S. TRUSTEES 168,000
632483 Lnd: 46,400 Bld: 168,000 Tot: 214,400
MACK, THOMAS W. 26600 JEFFERSON CT BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MACK, THOMAS W. 26600 JEFFERSON CT BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-20-047 5100 R 26705 MIDLAND RD 02/28/14 127,450 1.100 Y 1
JARVI, AARON L. & JANE H. SURVIVORSH DOBBINS CARL D. & JUDITH A. 107,600
634401 298740 Lnd: 32,000 Bld: 107,600 Tot: 139,600
JARVI, AARON L. 26705 MIDLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
JARVI, AARON L. 26705 MIDLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 3

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

203-20-080 5100 R 26702 HENRY RD 02/26/14 130,000 .940 Y 1
DUBINSKY, KAREN A WARRANTY D SIEMINSKI STANLEY E 86,100
633688 298349 Lnd: 35,900 Bld: 86,100 Tot: 122,000
KAREN A DUBINSKY 26702 HENRY RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
KAREN A DUBINSKY 2872 WMARKET ST AKRON, OH 44333

203-24-048 5100 R 26412 KNICKERBOCKER RD 02/10/14 0 .000 Y 1
JONES, ROGER M LIMITED WA FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI 89,400
631515 Lnd: 32,100 Bld: 89,400 Tot: 121,500
ROGER M JONES 26412 KNICKERBOCKER RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
ROGER M JONES 29089 NORTHFIELD RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

p>

203-27-025 5100 R 00438 CANTERBURY RD 02/19/14 129,000 .940 Y 1
THOMAS, SCOTT E. AND THOMAS, SUSAN SURVIVORSH ARCARO MICHAEL J JR 94,500
632559 297979 Lnd: 27,300 Bld: 94,500 Tot: 121,800
THOMAS, SCOTT E. AND THOMAS, SUSAN 00438 CANTERBURY RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
THOMAS, SCOTT E. AND THOMAS, SUSAN 438 CANTERBURY RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-28-064 5100 R 00403 ELMWOOD RD 02/06/14 177,500 .850 Y 1
COCCO, TODD C. WARRANTY D REICHLIN, DIANNE M. 124,100
631092 297381 Lnd: 25,900 Bld: 124,100 Tot: 150,000
COCCO, TODD C. 00403 ELMWOOD RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
COCCO, TODD C. 403 ELMWOOD DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-30-036 5100 R 00615 PARKSIDE DR 02/11/14 78,225 2.160 Y 1
CROLEY, ANDREW S LIMITED WA NATIONSTAR MORTGAGE, LLC 141,800
631589 297581 Lnd: 26,800 Bld: 141,800 Tot: 168,600
ANDREW S CROLEY 00615 PARKSIDE DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
ANDREW S CROLEY 8025 BAUSER AVE ROSEVILLE, CA 95747

204-01-061 5100 R 00567 JUNEWAY DR 02/28/14 125,000 1.140 Y 1
COOPER, KRISTIN KAY WARRANTY D FISHHOUSE EMTERPRISES LLC 117,100
634154 298589 Lnd: 26,000 Bld: 117,100 Tot: 143,100
COOPER, KRISTIN KAY 00567 JUNEWAY DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
COOPER, KRISTIN KAY 567 JUNEWAY DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 4

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

204-02-003 5100 R 00541 OAKMOOR AVE 02/10/14 125,475 1.030 Y 1
RC GRAY LLC QUIT CLAIM NATIONSTAR MORTGAGE LLC 102,800
631499 297549 Lnd: 26,100 Bld: 102,800 Tot: 128,900
RC GRAY LLC 00541 OAKMOOR AVE BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
RC GRAY LLC 541 OAKMOOR AVE BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-02-029 5100 R 00526 LAKE FOREST DR 02/11/14 0 .000 Y 1
MCDONALD, LINDA L.& MICHAEL W QUIT CLAIM MCDONALD, LINDA L. 132,900
631576 Lnd: 41,400 Bld: 132,900 Tot: 174,300
MCDONALD, LINDA L TRUSTEE 00526 LAKE FOREST DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MCDONALD, LINDA L TRUSTEE 526 LAKE FOREST DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-02-029 5100 R 00526 LAKE FOREST DR 02/11/14 0 .000 Y 1
MCDONALD, LINDA L TRUSTEE QUIT CLAIM MCDONALD, LINDA L.& MICHAEL W 132,900
631578 Lnd: 41,400 Bld: 132,900 Tot: 174,300
MCDONALD, LINDA L TRUSTEE 00526 LAKE FOREST DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MCDONALD, LINDA L TRUSTEE 526 LAKE FOREST DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-02-069 5100 R 00537 JUNEWAY DR 02/04/14 67,800 2.000 Y 1
HUGHES-ROYBAL, WENDY QUIT CLAIM HUGHES, MISTY K 96,600
630773 297252 Lnd: 39,000 Bld: 96,600 Tot: 135,600
HUGHES-ROYBAL, WENDY 00537 JUNEWAY DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
HUGHES-ROYBAL, WENDY 537 JUNEWAY DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-06-024 5100 R 00504 BAYFAIR DR 02/19/14 0 .000 Y 1
HOFFMAN SHERYL QUIT CLAIM HOFFMAN SHERYL 102,700
632475 Lnd: 29,100 Bld: 102,700 Tot: 131,800
HOFFMAN SHERYL 00504 BAYFAIR DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
HOFFMAN SHERYL 504 BAYFAIR DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-06-039 5100 R 00535 BAYFAIR DR 02/19/14 88,000 1.630 Y 1
WELLS FARGO BANK NA SHERIFFS D PSOTA, JILL T. 116,100
632456 297951 Lnd: 27,400 Bld: 116,100 Tot: 143,500
WELLS FARGO BANK NA 00535 BAYFAIR DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
WELLS FARGO BANK NA 3476 STATEVIEW BLVD FORT MILL, SC 29715
Page 5

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

204-09-007 5100 font size=2>R 25240 LAKE RD 02/19/14 0 .000 Y 1
HELGESEN GARY D – TRUSTEE AFFIDAVIT HELGESEN, HAZEL M (TRS) 140,900
632617 Lnd: 390,000 Bld: 140,900 Tot: 530,900
HELGESEN GARY D – TRUSTEE 25240 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
HELGESEN GARY D – TRUSTEE 25240 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-16-047 5100 R 00490 UPLAND RD 02/10/14 0 .000 Y 1
HATCHER, KATHERINE YORK JUDGEMENT HATCHER, RONALD L. 88,700
631491 Lnd: 49,500 Bld: 88,700 Tot: 138,200
KATHERINE YORK THATCHER 00490 UPLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
KATHERINE YORK THATCHER 14806 DETROIT AVE LAKEWOOD, OH 44107

204-21-030 5100 R 00462 FORDHAM PKWY 02/07/14 0 .000 Y 1
MAUGANS,., ELIZABETH H. & BANDO, J WARRANTY D MAUGANS, FERN S., ELIZABETH H. & B 137,700
631316 Lnd: 34,900 Bld: 137,700 Tot: 172,600
MAUGANS,., ELIZABETH H. 00462 FORDHAM PKWY BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MAUGANS,., ELIZABETH H. 462 FORDHAM PKWY BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

td width=6%>5100

204-28-070 R 00573 HUNTLEY CT 02/21/14 161,000 .940 Y 1
HARTZELL, CHRISTOPHER T. & JENNIFER SURVIVORSH EBRIGHT, PAUL – TRUSTEE 116,000
633039 298141 Lnd: 35,000 Bld: 116,000 Tot: 151,000
HARTZELL, CHRISTOPHER T. 00573 HUNTLEY CT BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
HARTZELL, CHRISTOPHER T. 573 HUNTLEY CT BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Total Number of Parcels: 32 Total Sales -5.00
Page 6

Sales File Validation

Sales Listing

BAY VILLAGE
Sales From: 2014-03-01 To 2014-03-31

Certified Year: 2013

Parcel Year: 2014

font size=3>Run Date: 4/1/2014

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

201-12-046 5100 R 31200 NARRAGANSETT LN 03/20/14 261,000 1.340 Y 1
FREDECKER, DAVID SHERIFFS D WAGNER DONALD E 269,300
637152 300033 Lnd: 80,600 Bld: 269,300 Tot: 349,900
FREDECKER, DAVID 31200 NARRAGANSETT LN BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
FREDECKER, DAVID 20646 BEACANSFIELD ROCKY RIVER, OH 44116

201-15-038 5100 R 31410 CARLTON DR 03/26/14 278,000 .920 Y 1
HILDE, JOHN R WARRANTY D HIPPLER, MICHAEL G. 209,700
638083 300416 Lnd: 47,000 Bld: 209,700 Tot: 256,700
HILDE, JOHN R 31410 CARLTON DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
HILDE, JOHN R 31410 CARLTON DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-16-025 5100 R 31108 CARLTON DR 03/26/14 189,000 .710 Y 1
WAFFEN, CHRISTOPHER & BORSOS, KATIE SURVIVORSH SHIGAR PARTNER, LLC 107,400
638003 300380 Lnd: 26,800 Bld: 107,400 Tot: 134,200
WAFFEN, CHRISTOPHER 31108 CARLTON DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
WAFFEN, CHRISTOPHER 31108 CARLTON DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-17-032 5100 R 30822 CARLTON DR 03/26/14 187,500 .780 Y 1
SPOLAR GARY LEE & DAWN MARIE WARRANTY D ARMSTRONG, ROBERT G. 120,100
638021 300390 Lnd: 26,400 Bld: 120,100 Tot: 146,500
SPOLAR GARY LEE 30822 CARLTON DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SPOLAR GARY LEE 30822 CARLTON DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 1

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

201-18-006 5100 R 00415 PELLETT DR 03/24/14 199,900 1.060 Y 1
ST. BARNABAS EPISCOPAL CHURCH WARRANTY D FABRITIUS, MARILYN & GUTIN, BARBARA 163,200
637620 300249 Lnd: 49,500 Bld: 163,200 Tot: 212,700
ST. BARNABAS EPISCOPAL CHURCH 00415 PELLETT DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
ST. BARNABAS EPISCOPAL CHURCH 415 PELLETT DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-18-019 5100 R 00400 PELLETT DR 03/06/14 0 .000 Y 1
BETTCHER, WALTER A AND DOLORES M – WARRANTY D BETTCHER, WALTER A 181,700
635312 Lnd: 49,300 Bld: 181,700 Tot: 231,000
BETTCHER, WALTER A AND DOLORES M – 00400 PELLETT DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
BETTCHER, WALTER A AND DOLORES M – 400 PELLETT DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-19-020 5100 R 00384 WALMAR DR 03/03/14 269,000 .890 Y 1
MAY, ANDREW J AND LEVINGSTON, JUSTI WARRANTY D KEVESDY, K. MARK & KIMBERLY A. 193,200
634752 298899 Lnd: 46,700 Bld: 193,200 Tot: 239,900
MAY, ANDREW J AND LEVINGSTON, JUSTI 00384 WALMAR DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MAY, ANDREW J AND LEVINGSTON, JUSTI 384 WALMAR DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-21-003 5100 R 00427 WALMAR DR 03/17/14 312,000 .850 Y 1
GILLETTE, EMILY J. & BRYAN R. SURVIVORSH DRABIK, MICHELLE 218,100
636751 299859 Lnd: 45,900 Bld: 218,100 Tot: 264,000
GILLETTE, EMILY J. 00427 WALMAR DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
GILLETTE, EMILY J. 427 WALMAR DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-21-024 5100 R 00442 BATES DR 03/13/14 71,500 2.570 Y 1
HOOVER, PEGGY A. WARRANTY-P LOVELAND, LINDA LEE ET AL 137,800
636373 299670 Lnd: 45,800 Bld: 137,800 Tot: 183,600
HOOVER, PEGGY A. 00442 BATES DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
HOOVER, PEGGY A. 442 BATES DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-21-024 5100 R 00442 BATES DR 03/13/14 71,500 2.570 Y 1
HOOVER, PEGGY A. WARRANTY-P HOOVER, PEGGY A. 137,800
636374 299671 Lnd: 45,800 Bld: 137,800 Tot: 183,600
HOOVER, PEGGY A. 00442 BATES DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
HOOVER, PEGGY A. 442 BATES DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 2

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

201-21-024 5100 R 00442 BATES DR 03/13/14 71,500 2.570 Y 1
HOOVER, PEGGY A. WARRANTY-P HOOVER, PEGGY A. 137,800
636375 299672 Lnd: 45,800 Bld: 137,800 Tot: 183,600
HOOVER, PEGGY A. 00442 BATES DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
HOOVER, PEGGY A. 442 BATES DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-30-011 5100 R 30480 TIMBER LN 03/18/14 454,000 .700 Y 1
SARGENT, JILEEN C. WARRANTY D SHERWIN, MICHAEL J & MICHELLE T 267,000
636890 299923 Lnd: 50,700 Bld: 267,000td>

Tot: 317,700
SARGENT, JILEEN C. 30480 TIMBER LN BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SARGENT, JILEEN C. 30480 TIMBER LN BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-37-002 5100 R 00428 BASSETT RD 03/21/14 0 .000 Y 2
ANDRASSY, JAMES J., CO- TRS. & ANDR WARRANTY D ANDRASSY JAMES J & SUSAN R 147,800
637324 Lnd: 28,700 Bld: 147,800 Tot: 176,500
ANDRASSY, JAMES J., CO- TRS. & 00428 BASSETT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
ANDRASSY, JAMES J., CO- TRS. & 428 BASSETT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140-1800

201-37-003 5000 R BASSETT RD 03/21/14 0 .000 Y 2
ANDRASSY, JAMES J., CO- TRS. & ANDR WARRANTY D ANDRASSY, JAMES J & SUSAN R 0
637324 Lnd: 7,600 Bld: 0 Tot: 7,600
ANDRASSY, JAMES J., CO- TRS. BASSETT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
ANDRASSY, JAMES J., CO- TRS. 428 BASSETT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-37-027 5100 R 30008 WOLF RD 03/20/14 0 .000 Y 1
MCDONALD, CAROL ANN TRS. WARRANTY D MC DONALD CHARLES D & CAROL 151,700
637124 Lnd: 50,600b> Bld: 151,700 Tot: 202,300
MCDONALD, CAROL ANN TRS. 30008 WOLF RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MCDONALD, CAROL ANN TRS. 30008 WOLF RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140-1613

202-02-014 5100 R 29445 LAKE RD 03/21/14 256,700 1.060 Y 1
SMITH, SCOTT A. & BEATE BLAICH SURVIVORSH MCCORMICK, LOIS I 232,300
637492 300192 Lnd: 40,700 Bld: 232,300 Tot: 273,000
SMITH, SCOTT A. 29445 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SMITH, SCOTT A. 29445 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 3

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

202-08-008 5100 R 29529 GOULDERS GREEN RD 03/14/14 408,800 .780 Y 1
MASTERSON, JENNIFER M AND MICHAEL S SURVIVORSH CARTER, WILLIAM H. & SALLY J. 252,700
636529 299736 Lnd: 66,900 Bld: 252,700 Tot: 319,600
MASTERSON, JENNIFER M AND MICHAEL S 29529 GOULDERS GREEN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MASTERSON, JENNIFER M AND MICHAEL S 29529 GOLDDERS GREEN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-18-014 5100 R 00576 BASSETT RD 03/14/14 0 .000 Y 1
FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORAT SHERIFFS D DIBENEDETTO, DAVID S. 100,900
636403 Lnd: 31,200 Bld: 100,900 Tot: 132,100
FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORAT 00576 BASSETT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORAT 8200 JONES BRANCH DR MCLEAN, VA 22102

/p>

202-18-033 5100 R 00585 YARMOUTH LN 03/07/14 0 .000 Y 1
SHOWALTER, ELIZABETH ANN TRS. WARRANTY D SHOWALTER, ELIZABETH 189,200
635532 Lnd: 42,100 Bld: 189,200 Tot: 231,300
SHOWALTER, ELIZABETH ANN TRS. 00585 YARMOUTH LN BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SHOWALTER, ELIZABETH ANN TRS. 585 YARMOUTH DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-21-015 5100 R 00511 SHERWOOD DR 03/27/14 171,000 .980 Y 1
ELLIOTT DANIEL J & MARY JANE SURVIVORSH BRUHN, LEONARD V. 134,500
638217 300475 Lnd: 32,900 Bld: 134,500 Tot: 167,400
FIFTH THIRD 00511 SHERWOOD DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
FIFTH THIRD 5001 KINGSLEY CINCINNATI, OH 45227

202-23-038 5100 R 29604 WEST OAKLAND RD 03/07/14 415,000 .670 Y 1
LEEK, WILLIAM C WARRANTY D KELLY, MITCHELL W. 220,500
635710 299379 Lnd: 56,000 Bld: 220,500 Tot: 276,500
LEEK, WILLIAM C 29604 WEST OAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
LEEK, WILLIAM C 14806 DETROIT LAKEWOOD, OH 44107

202-28-042 5100 R 28304 OSBORN RD 03/12/14 439,000 .670 Y 1
DODD, GARY W. JR. & CATHY SURVIVORSH SCHOTTELKOTTE, LOUIS A & MARGARET T 248,100
636228 299615 Lnd: 46,900 Bld: 248,100 Tot: 295,000/font>
DODD, GARY W. JR. 28304 OSBORN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DODD, GARY W. JR. 28304 OSBORN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 4

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

202-32-039 5100 Rfont> 00630 REVERE DR 03/21/14 0 .000 Y 1
SCHELL, CHRISTIAN F. AFFIDAVIT SCHELL CHRISTIAN F & CAROL J 152,800
637423 Lnd: 44,200 Bld: 152,800 Tot: 197,000
SCHELL, CHRISTIAN F. 00630 REVERE DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SCHELL, CHRISTIAN F. 630 REVERE DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140-1971

203-09-017 5100 R 00467 CAHOON RD 03/05/14 96,000 1.140 Y 1
CHARLES, MORGAN WARRANTY D CSISZAR, ATTILA & JACKOLIN 84,000
635249 299169 Lnd: 25,500 Bld: 84,000 Tot: 109,500
CHARLES, MORGAN 00467 CAHOON RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
CHARLES, MORGAN 467 CAHOON RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-15-017 5100 R 00290 GLEN PARK DR 03/13/14 0 .000 Y 1
BOLDT, DAVID R.,TRS & REHORT, DANIE AFFIDAVIT SKONY, JACQUELINE & REHOR DANIEL TR 110,400
636253 Lnd: 40,200 Bld: 110,400 Tot: 150,600
BOLDT, DAVID R., TRS. & REHORT, DAN 00290 GLEN PARK DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
BOLDT, DAVID R., TRS. & REHORT, DAN 6900 ACRES DR INDEPENDENCE, OH 44131

203-16-014 5100 R 27028 NORMANDY RD 03/27/14 165,000 .920 Y 1
INMAN DANIEL R WARRANTY D ACKERMAN, JENNIFER A. 123,200
638302 300537 Lnd: 28,200 Bld: 123,200 Tot: 151,400
INMAN DANIEL R 27028 NORMANDY RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
INMAN DANIEL R 27028 NORMANDY RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-18-045 5100 R 26532 WOLF RD 03/07/14 176,500 1.000 Y 1
O’LEARY, DAN E. JR. FIDUCIARY CAHILL, MICHAEL B SUC-TRUSTEE 139,900
635674 299355 Lnd: 37,200 Bld: 139,900 Tot: 177,100
O’LEARY, DAN E. JR. 26532 WOLF RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
O’LEARY, DAN E. JR. 1525 PRINCE CHARLES AVE WESTLAKE, OH 44145

203-20-095 5100 R 26708 OSBORN RD 03/13/14 0 .000 Y 1
BENNET, KATHERINE H. QUIT CLAIM BENNET, KATHERINE H. TRS 141,500
636363 Lnd: 30,100 Bld: 141,500 Tot: 171,600
BENNET, KATHERINE H. 26708 OSBORN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
BENNET, KATHERINE H. 26708 OSBORN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 5

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

203-24-019 5100td>

R 26518 KNICKERBOCKER RD 03/14/14 85,000 1.570 Y 1
BRUMAGIN, SCOTT L. & SHARON K. SURVIVORSH KRISHER, GARY E. 104,300
636580 299768 Lnd: 28,800 Bld: 104,300 Tot: 133,100
BRUMAGIN, SCOTT L. 26518 KNICKERBOCKER RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
BRUMAGIN, SCOTT L. 26518 KNICKERBOCKER RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-26-020 5100 R 00524 CANTERBURY RD 03/17/14 0 .000 Y 1
KETTE, DAVID P. & REBECCA E. SURVIVORSH KETTE, DAVID P 124,200
636719 Lnd: 26,800 Bld: 124,200 Tot: 151,000
KETTE, DAVID P. 00524 CANTERBURY RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
KETTE, DAVID P. 524 CANTERBURY RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-27-042 5100 R 00459 CANTERBURY RD 03/24/14 140,000 .860 Y 1
SMITH, SCOTT HOWARD WARRANTY D SOVOL, BECKY A. & HORNE, CHRISTOPHE 93,700
637626 300252 Lnd: 27,300 Bld: 93,700 Tot: 121,000
SMITH, SCOTT HOWARD 00459 CANTERBURY RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SMITH, SCOTT HOWARD 459 CANTERBURY RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-28-057 5100 R 00366 ELMWOOD RD 03/14/14 131,300 1.080 Y 1
HIPPLER, SUZANNE M. SURVIVORSH STEPHENS, IAN M. 115,500
636588 299775 Lnd: 25,900 Bld: 115,500 Tot: 141,400
HIPPLER, SUZANNE M. 00366 ELMWOOD RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
HIPPLER, SUZANNE M. 366 ELMWOOD RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-28-071 5100 R 00361 ELMWOOD RD 03/13/14 0 .000 Y 1
SIENNA HOLDINGS LLC QUIT CLAIM WALSH, SEAMUS J. & LAURIE A. 92,700
636372 Lnd: 25,900 Bld: 92,700 Tot: 118,600
SIENNA HOLDINGS LLC 00361 ELMWOOD RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SIENNA HOLDINGS LLC 361 ELMWOOD RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-28-096 5100 R 00400 KENILWORTH RD 03/21/14 0 .000 Y 1
SARDINAS, LESLIE AFFIDAVIT BOLES RUTH SPIEWAK 83,200
637424 Lnd: 25,900 Bld: 83,200 Tot: 109,100
SARDINAS, LESLIE 00400 KENILWORTH RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SARDINAS, LESLIE 400 KENILWORTH RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140-2472
Page 6

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

203-31-012 5100 R 00499 KENILWORTH RD 03/03/14 0 .000 Y 1
ASHBROOK, KATHLEEN MCCARTHY QUIT CLAIM MWA & KMA 94,100font>
634539 Lnd: 27,000 Bld: 94,100 Tot: 121,100
ASHBROOK, KATHLEEN MCCARTHY 00499 KENILWORTH RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
ASHBROOK, KATHLEEN MCCARTHY 499 KENILWORTH BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-33-039 5100 R 00366 HUNTMERE RD 03/03/14 117,000 1.040 Y 1
SHUTT, BYRON M. & SHUTT, JULIA M. SURVIVORSH SPENCE, DONALD 90,600
634774 298913 Lnd: 31,400 Bld: 90,600 Tot: 122,000
SHUTT, BRYON M. & SHUTT, JULIA M. 00366 HUNTMERE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SHUTT, BRYON M. & SHUTT, JULIA M. 29723 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-33-074 5100 R 00394 OAKMOOR AVE 03/05/14 76,000 2.030 Y 1
LAKE PROPERTIES LTD SHERIFFS D MISLANSKY, PATRICIA L. 127,800
635043 299075 Lnd: 26,200 Bld: 127,800 Tot: 154,000
WEBER, CHRISTINE M. 00394 OAKMOOR AVE BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
WEBER, CHRISTINE M. 394 OAKMOOR AVE BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-33-074 5100 R 00394 OAKMOOR AVE 03/14/14 75,000 2.050 Y 1
WEBER, CHRISTINE M. WARRANTY D LAKE PROPERTIES LTD 127,800
636571 299762 Lnd: 26,200 Bld: 127,800 Tot: 154,000
WEBER, CHRISTINE M. 00394 OAKMOOR AVE BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
WEBER, CHRISTINE M. 394 OAKMOOR AVE BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-01-094 5100 R 25711 EATON WAY 03/07/14 0 .000 Y 1
MARTIN, DONNA M AFFIDAVIT MARTIN LUELLA I. 108,300
635528 Lnd: 29,300 Bld: 108,300 Tot: 137,600
DONNA A MARTIN 25711 EATON WAY BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DONNA A MARTIN 25711 EATON WAY BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140-2503

204-05-085 5100 R 24951 BAYFAIR CT 03/20/14 0 .000 Y 1
LEHMAN, KEVIN B & KIMBERLY A. SURVIVORSH LEHMAN, KEVIN B 112,200
637237 Lnd: 26,600 Bld: 112,200 Tot: 138,800
LEHMAN, KEVIN B 24951 BAYFAIR CT BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
LEHMAN, KEVIN B 24951 BAYFAIR CT BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 7

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

204-05-100 5100 R 00575 RED OAK LN 03/21/14 205,000 .970 Y 1
WALTERS, JUSTIN & JESSICA J. SURVIVORSH ROSSI, BETH 170,700
637476 300179 Lnd: 27,400 Bld: 170,700 Tot: 198,100
WALTERS, JUSTIN & JESSICA J. 00575 RED OAK LN BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
WALTERS, JUSTIN & JESSICA J. 575 RED OAK LN BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-15-041 5100 R 00576 UPLAND RD 03/18/14 189,000 .770 Y 1
SCHEIMANN, LARAINE WARRANTY D MASSINGILL, JEANNE 119,000
636916 299938 Lnd: 26,200 Bld: 119,000 Tot: 145,200
SCHEIMANN, LARAINE 00576 UPLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SCHEIMANN, LARAINE 576 UPLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-17-025 5100 R 24418 BRUCE RD 03/06/14 0 .000 Y 1
BEAL, CLAUDIA D. TRUSTEE WARRANTY D BEAL, KURT A. & CLAUDIA D. 199,000
635355 Lnd: 46,300 Bld: 199,000 Tot: 245,300
BEAL, CLAUDIA D. TRUSTEE 24418 BRUCE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
BEAL, CLAUDIA D. TRUSTEE 24418 BRUCE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-18-003 5000 R 00000 LAKE RD 03/21/14 0 .000 Y 1
24528 LAKE ROAD LLC FIDUCIARY MARINIK,MARK & ELIZABETH C 0
637473 Lnd: 269,100 Bld: 0 Tot: 269,100
24528 LAKE ROAD LLC 00000 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
24528 LAKE ROAD LLC 25424 LAKE RD ROCKY RIVER, OH 44116

204-20-067 5100 R 23928 WOLF RD 03/25/14 0 .000 Y 1
PIERMAN, HELEN CHRISTINE ET AL AFFIDAVIT OBERAITIS, HELNE P. 129,800
637770 Lnd: 35,900 Bld: 129,800 Tot: 165,700
PIERMAN, HELEN CHRISTINE ET AL 23928 WOLF RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
PIERMAN, HELEN CHRISTINE ET AL 23928 WOLF RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140-2857

204-21-012 5100 R 24014 RUSSELL RD 03/07/14 0 .000 Y 1
HUGHES, SCOTT – TRUSTEE PROBATE CO HUGHES MINA L 87,500
635509 Lnd: 50,000 Bld: 87,500 Tot: 137,500
HUGHES, SCOTT – TRUSTEE 24014 RUSSELL RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
HUGHES, SCOTT – TRUSTEE 24014 RUSSELL RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 8

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

204-25-816C 5500 R 23104 ROBERT’S RUN 74 03/21/14 0 .000 Y 1
PILKEY, DAVID M. TRUSTEE WARRANTY D PILKEY, DAVID M. 322,100
637532 Lnd: 35,800 Bld: 322,100 Tot: 357,900
PILKEY, DAVID M. TRUSTEE 23104 ROBERT’S RUN 74 BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
PILKEY, DAVID M. TRUSTEE 23104 ROBERT’S RUN UNIT 74 BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-25-824C 5500 R 00355 ROBERT’S RUN 104 03/05/14 184,000 1.540 Y 1
CONWAY, JOSEPH A & DEBRA A SURVIVORSH DER, GABRIELLA & MCCARTY, JOHN M. 255,800
635259 299175 Lnd: 28,400 Bld: 255,800 Tot: 284,200
CONWAY, JOSEPH A 00355 ROBERT’S RUN 104 BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
CONWAY, JOSEPH A 355 ROBERT’S RUN UNIT 104 BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-26-011 5100 R 23712 WOLF RD 03/14/14 0 .000 Y 1
FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI SHERIFFS D REUST, BRADLEY A 113,500
636415 Lnd: 32,200 Bld: 113,500 Tot: 145,700
FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI 23712 WOLF RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI P.O. BOX 650043 DALLAS, TX 75265

204-28-010 5100 R 00556 HUMISTON DR 03/28/14 125,000 1.370 Y 1
BAUMAN, MICHAEL C FIDUCIARY SHEAR JACK G 140,900
638389 300564 Lnd: 30,500 Bld: 140,900 Tot: 171,400
STONEGATE MORTGAGE 00556 HUMISTON DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
STONEGATE MORTGAGE PO BOX 336 MANSFIELD, OH 44901
Total Number of Parcels: 50 Total Sales -8.00
Page 9

Sales File Validation

Sales Listing

BAY VILLAGE
Sales From: 2014-04-01 To 2014-04-30

Certified Year: 2013

Parcel Year: 2014

Run Date: 5/2/2014

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

201-02-016 5100 R 31328 LAKE RD 04/15/14 249,500 .970 Y 1
DILLER DAUN LEISA WARRANTY D BEHEIM CHRIS W 115,400
641000 301742 Lnd: 127,600 Bld: 115,400 Tot: 243,000
DILLER DAUN LEISA 31328 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DILLER DAUN LEISA 4 SUMMIT PARK DR INDEPENDENCE, OH 44131

201-02-050 5100 R 00061 EAGLE CLIFF DR 04/14/14 111,200 1.180 Y 1
LANDVIEWS LLC SHERIFFS D BROWN, JEFFREY A. 100,500
640623 301590 Lnd: 30,800 Bld: 100,500 Tot: 131,300
LANDVIEWS LLC 00061 EAGLE CLIFF DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
LANDVIEWS LLC 130 MURCOTT CIR CHAGRIN FALLS, OH 44022

201-04-010 5100 R 30734 LAKE RD 04/04/14 455,500 1.590 Y 1
ROEHL, DANIEL J. & CHRISTINE C. LIMITED WA HSBC BANK USA NATIONAL ASSOCIATION 588,400
639424 301047 Lnd: 137,600 Bld: 588,400 Tot: 726,000
ROEHL, DANIEL J. 30734 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
ROEHL, DANIEL J. 30734 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-05-012 5100 R 30505 LAKE RD 04/17/14 415,000 .870 Y 1
CLAPP, TERESA L WARRANTY D MULHERN, JULIE M 313,000
641353 301903 Lnd: 46,600 Bld: 313,000 Tot: 359,600
CLAPP, TERESA L 30505 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
CLAPP, TERESA L 30505 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 1

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

201-06-010 5100 R 30200 LAKE RD 04/03/14 0 .000 Y 1
KALISH, TODD C. QUIT CLAIM KALISH, TODD C. & JULIE M. 315,700
639220 /td>

Lnd: 262,000 Bld: 315,700 Tot: 577,700
KALISH, TODD C. 30200 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
KALISH, TODD C. 30200 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-10-019 5100 R 31201 ROXBURY PARK DR 04/02/14 0 .000 Y 1
DIGIOVANNI, SUE & MADDEN, SARA & KI AFFIDAVIT KIM, YUN HWA 389,700
638976 Lnd: 82,200 Bld: 389,700 Tot: 471,900
DIGIOVANNI, SUE 31201 ROXBURY PARK DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DIGIOVANNI, SUE 31201 ROXBURY PARK DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-12-044 5100 R 31104 NARRAGANSETT LN 04/29/14 0 .000 Y 1
COWELL, CAROL A -TRUSTEE & COWELL, WARRANTY D COWELL CHARLES E & CAROL A 239,600
642793 Lnd: 78,700 Bld: 239,600 Tot: 318,300
COWELL, CAROL A -TRUSTEE 31104 NARRAGANSETT LN BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
COWELL, CAROL A -TRUSTEE 31104 NARRAGANSETT LN BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-15-006 5100 R 31329 WALKER RD 04/28/14 0 .000 Y 1
KOLIVAS, RUTH E AFFIDAVIT KOLIVAS, LOUIS P. 131,000
642590 Lnd: 33,500 Bld: 131,000 Tot: 164,500
KOLIVAS, RUTH E 31329 WALKER RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
KOLIVAS, RUTH E 31329 WALKER RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-16-034 5100 R 31005 CARLTON DR 04/24/14 155,000 .930 Y 1

td width=30%>BAUMAN, LISA A

WARRANTY D BODUCH, HEATHER L 116,300
642178 302260 Lnd: 28,500 Bld: 116,300 Tot: 144,800
BAUMAN, LISA A 31005 CARLTON DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
BAUMAN, LISA A 31005 CARLTON DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-16-071 5100 R 00369 BAR HARBOR DR 04/10/14 240,000 .800 Y 1
KROFFKE, BRANDON & MANNIX, DANA SURVIVORSH WASSMER, DANIEL P. & TAMMY M. 149,800
640274 301402 Lnd: 42,200 Bld: 149,800 Tot: 192,000
KROFFKE, BRANDON 00369 BAR HARBOR DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
KROFFKE, BRANDON 369 BAR HARBOR DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 2

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bldfont>
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

201-17-008 5100 R 00318 BRADLEY RD 04/16/14 187,000 .910 Y 1
CURRAN GEORGE & JILL SURVIVORSH SAURMAN, JAN A. & CAROL E. CO-TRUST 143,700
641193 301859 Lnd: 27,400 Bld: 143,700 Tot: 171,100
CURRAN GEORGE & JILL 00318 BRADLEY RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
CURRAN GEORGE & JILL 18303 GRIDLEY RD CERRITOS, CA 90703

201-21-029 5100 R 00423 BATES DR 04/21/14 245,000 .700 Y 1
IRWIN, CHRISTOPHER S. & ANNA SURVIVORSH GOULD, JAMIE B. CARPENTER 125,900
641750 302085 Lnd: 46,100 Bld: 125,900 Tot: 172,000
IRWIN, CHRISTOPHER S. 00423 BATES DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
IRWIN, CHRISTOPHER S. 423 BATES DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-26-033 5100 R 00607 WALMAR DR 04/17/14 0 .000 Y 1
LIATTI, DENNIS QUIT CLAIM LIATTI, DENNIS M 177,600
641291 Lnd: 49,300 Bld: 177,600 Tot: 226,900
LIATTI, DENNIS 00607 WALMAR DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
LIATTI, DENNIS 607 WALMAR DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-31-031 5100 R 00301 SADDLER RD 04/03/14 142,000 1.260 Y 2
BARNEY, CULLEN P WARRANTY D ALDRETE MARY 136,500
639294 300987 Lnd: 42,400 Bld: 136,500 Tot: 178,900
CULLEN P BARNEY 00301 SADDLER RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
CULLEN P BARNEY 622 YARMOUTH DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-31-042 5000 R SADDLER RD REAR 04/03/14 142,000 .090 Y 2
BARNEY, CULLEN P WARRANTY D ALDRETE MARY 0
639294 300987 Lnd: 12,800 Bld: 0 Tot: 12,800
CULLEN P BARNEY SADDLER RD REAR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
CULLEN P BARNEY 622 YARMOUTH DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-32-028 5100 R 00293 BREEZEWOOD DR 04/16/14 320,000 .870 Y 1
MILETI, MICHAEL S. AND MILETI, KELL SURVIVORSH SPOLAR, GARY L. 211,600
641198 301861 Lnd: 66,400 Bld: 211,600 Tot: 278,000
MILETI, MICHAEL S. AND MILETI, KELL 00293 BREEZEWOOD DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MILETI, MICHAEL S. AND MILETI, KELL 293 BREEZEWOOD DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 3

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

202-01-023 5100 R 00299 BASSETT RD 04/11/14 105,000 1.290 Y 1
QUALITY SELECT HOMES LLC WARRANTY D THIRD FEDERAL SAVINGS AND LOAN ASSO 103,000
640548 301544 Lnd: 32,700 Bld: 103,000 Tot: 135,700
QUALITY SELECT HOMES LLC 00299 BASSETT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
QUALITY SELECT HOMES LLC 30211 CHATHAM PT BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-04-041 5100 R 00344 LONGBEACH PKWY 04/09/14 0 .000 Y 1
MAJER MARK QUIT CLAIM MAJER MARK 156,600
640007 Lnd: 42,300 Bld: 156,600 Tot: 198,900
MAJER MARK 00344 LONGBEACH PKWY BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MAJER MARK 344 LANGBEACH PKWY BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-06-026 5100 R 29711 FOOTE AVE 04/11/14 110,000 1.240 Y 1
MAYBAUM, DIANE & MICHAEL SURVIVORSH MCLAUGHLIN, THOMAS J. 108,500
640574 301564 Lnd: 27,600 Bld: 108,500 Tot: 136,100
MAYBAUM, DIANE 29711 FOOTE AVE BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MAYBAUM, DIANE 29711 FOOTE AVE BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-17-020 5100 R 30212 CHATHAM POINT DR 04/14/14 0 .000 Y 1
SILVESTRO HAZEL G AFFIDAVIT SILVESTRO RALPH P & HAZEL G 156,300
640717 Lnd: 40,000 Bld: 156,300 Tot: 196,300
SILVESTRO HAZEL G 30212 CHATHAM POINT DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SILVESTRO HAZEL G 30212 CHATHAM POINT DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-19-026 5100 R 30300 CRESTVIEW DR 04/15/14 0 .000 Y 1
DIETZ, THERESE J. & OESTRINGEN, JOA SURVIVORSH DIETZ, THERESE J. 213,200
640959 Lnd: 40,200 Bld: 213,200 Tot: 253,400
DIETZ, THERESE J. 30300 CRESTVIEW DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DIETZ, THERESE J. 30300 CRESTVIEW DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-20-004 5100 R 00514 BASSETT RD 04/18/14 183,500 .990 Y 1
NEILSEN MICHELLE J WARRANTY D RADEL, VICTOR D. 148,500
641559 302018 Lnd: 32,900 Bld: 148,500 Tot: 181,400
NEILSEN MICHELLE J 00514 BASSETT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
NEILSEN MICHELLE J 514 BASSETT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 4

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

202-24-005 5100 R 29394 OSBORN RD 04/22/14 0 .000 Y 3
GLYNIAS, MANUEL P AND HEIDI M SURVIVORSH GLYNIAS, MANUEL P. & HEIDI M. 126,000
641940 Lnd: 56,500 Bld: 126,000 Tot: 182,500
GLYNIAS, MANUEL P AND HEIDI M 29394 OSBORN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
GLYNIAS, MANUEL P AND HEIDI M 29485 WOLF RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-24-006 5100 R 29404 OSBORN RD 04/22/14 0 .000 Y 3
GLYNIAS, MANUEL P AND HEIDI M SURVIVORSH GLYNIAS, MANUEL P. & HEIDI M. 596,800
641940 Lnd: 91,200 Bld: 596,800 Tot: 688,000
GLYNIAS, MANUEL P AND HEIDI M 29404 OSBORN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
GLYNIAS, MANUEL P AND HEIDI M 29485 WOLF RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-24-012 5100 R 29485 WOLF RD 04/22/14 0 .000 Y 3
GLYNIAS, MANUEL P AND HEIDI M SURVIVORSH GLYNIAS, MANUEL P 109,500
641940 Lnd: 80,500 Bld: 109,500 Tot: 190,000
GLYNIAS, MANUEL P AND HEIDI M 29485 WOLF RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
GLYNIAS, MANUEL P AND HEIDI M 29485 WOLF RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-25-033 5100 R 00499 BRACKEN WAY 04/23/14 401,000 .770 Y 1
VEROSTKO, ANTHONY R. & TAMBURRO, JO WARRANTY D HORRIGAN, BRUCE D 249,600
642068 302206 Lnd: 59,700 Bld: 249,600 Tot: 309,300
ANTHONY R. VEROSTKO & JOAN E. TAMBU 00499 BRACKEN WAY BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

/table>

ANTHONY R. VEROSTKO & JOAN E. TAMBU 7007 BROADWAY AVE CLEVELAND, OH 44105
202-36-010 5100 R 00627 BASSETT RD 04/07/14 0 .000 Y 1
FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI SHERIFFS D ANGELO, JEAN M 130,600
639560 Lnd: 34,500 Bld: 130,600 Tot: 165,100
FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI 00627 BASSETT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI PO BOX 650043 DALLAS, TX 75265

203-03-065 5100 R 27881 WEST OAKLAND RD 04/15/14 0 .000 Y 1
CHRISTEL, THOMAS P. LIMITED WA FANNIE MAE 110,700
640996 Lnd: 28,200 Bld: 110,700 Tot: 138,900
CHRISTEL, THOMAS P. 27881 WEST OAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
CHRISTEL, THOMAS P. 27881 WOAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 5

Parcel Luctd>

Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

203-03-078 5100 R 28012 OSBORN RD 04/23/14 171,000 1.000 Y 1
KEVESDY, KENNETH M AND KIMBERLY A WARRANTY D KIRBY, RITA M. 142,000
641977 302185 Lnd: 29,600 Bld: 142,000 Tot: 171,600
KEVESDY, KENNETH M AND KIMBERLY A 28012 OSBORN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
KEVESDY, KENNETH M AND KIMBERLY A 28012 OSBORN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-07-005 5100 R 27889 LINCOLN RD 04/11/14 0 .000 Y 1
FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORAT SHERIFFS D HEPP ALOYSIUS F. 81,600
640357 Lnd: 25,800 Bld: 81,600 Tot: 107,400
FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORAT 27889 LINCOLN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
FEDERAL HOME LOAN MORTGAGE CORPORAT 8250 JONES BRANCH DR MCLEAN, VA 22102

203-08-033 5100 R 27814 REXFORD AVE 04/15/14 71,500 1.360 Y 1
ADAMS, SCOTT J. & ADAMS, KAREN O. SURVIVORSH SLEEPER REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS LTD 71,800
640905 301697 Lnd: 25,700 Bld: 71,800 Tot: 97,500
SLEEPER REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS LTD 27814 REXFORD AVE BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SLEEPER REAL ESTATE HOLDINGS LTD 206 BRADLEY RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-08-040 5100 R 27850 REXFORD AVE 04/10/14 107,000 .780 Y 1
CLEARY OWEN M & WISE KELLEN P WARRANTY D MCNALLY, SHEILA K. 57,500
640241 301379 Lnd: 25,700 Bld: 57,500 Tot: 83,200
CLEARY OWEN M 27850 REXFORD AVE BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
CLEARY OWEN M 27850 REXFORD AVE BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-12-014 5000 R 00597 CAHOON LEDGES RD 04/10/14 45,000 .400 Y 1
SWEITZER PROPERTY MANAGEMENT, LLC WARRANTY D THE KRUEGER GROUP, INC 0
640293 301414 Lnd: 17,800 Bld: 0 Tot: 17,800
SWEITZER PROPERTY MANAGEMENT, LLC 00597 CAHOON LEDGES RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SWEITZER PROPERTY MANAGEMENT, LLC 155 SAMUEL ST ELYRIA, OH 44035

203-12-025 5100 R 00618 CAHOON LEDGES RD 04/30/14 382,500 1.040 Y 1
EVANOFF, ERIC & MARJORIE SHERIFFS D LALLI, LORENZO S 286,100
643037 302692 Lnd: 111,800 Bld: 286,100 Tot: 397,900
EVANOFF, ERIC 00618 CAHOON LEDGES RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
EVANOFF, ERIC S/L 15 CAHOON LEDGE BAY VILLAGE, OH 44116
Page 6

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

203-15-021 5100 R 26714 BRUCE RD 04/30/14 233,000 .860 Y 1
SNOWGOLD, FRANK R. & SNOWGOLD, KELL TRUSTEE JOHNSON, HALLIE W – TRUSTEE – TRUST 155,300
643044 302702 Lnd: 44,400 Bld: 155,300 Tot: 199,700
SNOWGOLD, FRANK R. & SNOWGOLD, KELL 26714 BRUCE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SNOWGOLD, FRANK R. & SNOWGOLD, KELL 845 MCCORMICK DR LAKE FOREST, IL 60045

203-16-040 5100 R 27027 RUSSELL RD 04/25/14 0 .000 Y 1
TEUFEL, KELLY C., TRS. QUIT CLAIM GROSSNICKLE NANCY G 106,800
642387 Lnd: 36,800 Bld: 106,800 Tot: 143,600
TEUFEL, KELLY C., TRS. 27027 RUSSELL RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
TEUFEL, KELLY C., TRS. 27027 RUSSELL RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-18-057 5100 R 26509 RUSSELL RD 04/30/14 207,000 .950 Y 1
BITTINGER, STEPHEN D. & BITTINGER, SURVIVORSH ULIBARRI, JOSE & MARY RAE TRUSTE 151,000
642982 302666 Lnd: 45,100 Bld: 151,000 Tot: 196,100
BITTINGER, STEPHEN D. 26509 RUSSELL RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
BITTINGER, STEPHEN D. 26509 RUSSELL RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-22-039 4800 C 27105 KNICKERBOCKER RD 04/14/14 0 .000 Y 1
COUGER LLC QUIT CLAIM KRUEGER, JOSEPH D. 90,300
640764 Lnd: 60,100 Bld: 90,300 Tot: 150,400
COUGER LLC 27105 KNICKERBOCKER RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
COUGER LLC 25935 DETROIT RD 149 WESTLAKE, OH 44145

203-23-007 5100 R 26809 EAST OVIATT RD 04/18/14 0 .000 Y 1
FIEBELKORN, DAVID F. & GERMAE K. CORRECTIVE FIEBELKORN, GERMAE CO-TRS 62,900
641411 Lnd: 32,400 Bld: 62,900 Tot: 95,300
FIEBELKORN, DAVID F. 26809 EAST OVIATT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
FIEBELKORN, DAVID F. 26809 EOVIATT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-23-036 5100 R 26911 KNICKERBOCKER RD 04/29/14 67,000 1.900 Y 1
GULLA, ROBERT EDWARD – TRUSTEE WARRANTY D US BANK NATIONAL ASSOCIATION AS TRU 91,900
642849 302607 Lnd: 35,400 Bld: 91,900 Tot: 127,300
GULLA, ROBERT EDWARD – TRUSTEE 26911 KNICKERBOCKER RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
GULLA, ROBERT EDWARD – TRUSTEE 27016 KNICKERBOCKER RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 7

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

203-26-013 5100 R 00507 GLEN PARK DR 04/22/14 0 .000 Y 1
REISING, JOSEPH C. QUIT CLAIM REISING, JOSEPH C. & KELLY M. 113,800
641871 Lnd: 31,200 Bld: 113,800 Tot: 145,000
JOSEPH C. REISING 00507 GLEN PARK DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
JOSEPH C. REISING 507 GLEN PARK DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-27-080 5100 R 00449 ELMWOOD RD 04/16/14 167,000 .950 Y 1
CAHILL, BARBARA R. ET AL SURVIVORSH MILETI MICHAEL S. & MADGER KELLY A. 131,100
641147td>

301825 Lnd: 27,300 Bld: 131,100 Tot: 158,400
CAHILL, BARBARA R. ET AL 00449 ELMWOOD RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
CAHILL, BARBARA R. ET AL 449 ELMWOOD RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-28-096 5100 R 00400 KENILWORTH RD 04/25/14 100,000 1.090 Y 1
NORTON DAVID F & JUDITH H SURVIVORSH SARDINAS, LESLIE 83,200
642361 302346 Lnd: 25,900 Bld: 83,200 Tot: 109,100
DAVID F & JUDITH H NORTON 00400 KENILWORTH RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DAVID F & JUDITH H NORTON 4269 MALLARD COVE AVON, OH 44011

203-30-068 5100 R 25819 EATON WAY WAY 04/10/14 56,150 1.710 Y 1
PAVICIC, EDWARD P. LIMITED WA SECRETARY OF HOUSING & URBAN DEVELO 66,500
640265 301395 Lnd: 29,300 Bld: 66,500 Tot: 95,800
PAVICIC, EDWARD P. 25819 EATON WAY WAY BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
PAVICIC, EDWARD P. 359 LAKE PRK DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-31-026 5100 R 00512 PARKSIDE DR 04/28/14 0 .000 Y 1
BENNETT, ROBERT T., JR. QUIT CLAIM BENNETT, ROBERT T. SR & JR 124,400
642659 Lnd: 27,000 Bld: 124,400 Tot: 151,400
BENNETT, ROBERT T., JR. 00512 PARKSIDE DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
BENNETT, ROBERT T., JR. 512 PARKSIDE DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-32-049 5100 R 00426 HUNTMERE RD 04/21/14 0 .000 Y 1
CLARK, WILLIAM H. PROBATE CO CLARK EDITH F 92,300
641763 Lnd: 27,800 Bld: 92,300 Tot: 120,100
CLARK, WILLIAM H. 00426 HUNTMERE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
CLARK, WILLIAM H. 426 HUNTMERE DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140-2539
Page 8

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

203-33-033 5100 R 00334 HUNTMERE RD 04/01/14 0 .000 Y 1
GFU AFFIDAVIT, ELLIS, NICOLE MARIE 111,600
638840 Lnd: 27,800 Bld: 111,600 Tot: 139,400
GFU 00334 HUNTMERE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
GFU 334 HUNTMERE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-01-016 5100 R 00556 LAKE FOREST DR 04/30/14 152,500 .990 Y 1
REED, JAMES J. WARRANTY D DUBBERT, FREDERICK R. JR. 119,000
643085 302736 Lnd: 31,900 Bld: 119,000 Tot: 150,900
REED, JAMES J. 00556 LAKE FOREST DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
REED, JAMES J. 14806 DETROIT AVE LAKEWOOD, OH 44107

204-01-071 5100 R 00598 COLUMBIA RD 04/18/14 0 .000 Y 1
SMITH, CORY A. LIMITED WA FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI 106,700
641443 Lnd: 23,400 Bld: 106,700 Tot: 130,100
SMITH, CORY A. 00598 COLUMBIA RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SMITH, CORY A. 598 COLUMBIA RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-02-086 5100 R 00510 COLUMBIA RD 04/11/14 0 .000 Y 1
NASRALLAH, NABIL Y & NASRALLAH, ZAH SURVIVORSH NASRALLAH, NABIL Y 78,800
640585 Lnd: 28,600 Bld: 78,800 Tot: 107,400
NABIL Y NASRALLAH ET AL 00510 COLUMBIA RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
NABIL Y NASRALLAH ET AL 510 COLUMBIA RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-03-017 5100 R 00361 OAKMOOR AVE 04/02/14 136,000 1.070 Y 1
HANSEN, GERALD B. III & STOCKS, WHI SURVIVORSH FREIER ROBERT L 119,700
639120 300925 Lnd: 25,600 Bld: 119,700 Tot: 145,300
HANSEN, GERALD B. III 00361 OAKMOOR AVE BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
HANSEN, GERALD B. III 361 OAKMOOR AVE BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-10-058 5100 R 24925 FORESTVIEW RD 04/24/14 0 .000 Y 1
DORSEY, KIMBERLY S. AFFIDAVIT SULZMANN, MARTIN F. 105,100
642223 Lnd: 27,100 Bld: 105,100 Tot: 132,200
DORSEY, KIMBERLY S. 24925 FORESTVIEW RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DORSEY, KIMBERLY S. 14724 FERNWAY AVE CLEVELAND, OH 44111
Page 9

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

204-14-019 5100 R 24612 LAKE RD 04/04/14 0 .000 Y 1
PAVICIC, EDWARD WARRANTY D EDWARDS FINANCIAL GROUP, LLC 200,000
639458 Lnd: 62,800 Bld: 200,000 Tot: 262,800
PAVICIC, EDWARD 24612 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
PAVICIC, EDWARD 359 LAKE PARK DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-19-074 5100 R 24023 OAKLAND RD 04/04/14 155,300 .800 Y 1
KILBANE, MEGHAN B. WARRANTY Dtd>

NEAL, TIMOTHY J. 97,900
639423 301045 Lnd: 25,600 Bld: 97,900 Tot: 123,500
KILBANE, MEGHAN B. 24023 OAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
KILBANE, MEGHAN B. 24023 OAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-20-006 5100 R 00527 UPLAND RD 04/11/14/td>

171,000 .860 Y 1
LONG, MICHAEL R AND NANCY L FIDUCIARY MUSCA, KATHLEEN TRUSTEE 119,500
640590 301574 Lnd: 27,400 Bld: 119,500 Tot: 146,900
LONG, MICHAEL R AND NANCY L 00527 UPLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
LONG, MICHAEL R AND NANCY L 527 UPLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-21-042 5100 R 24139 LAKE RD 04/18/14 0 .000 Y 1
FIEBELKORN, DAVID F. & GERMAE K. CORRECTIVE FIEBELKORN, DAVID TRUSTEE 174,000
641413 Lnd: 47,400 Bld: 174,000 Tot: 221,400
FIEBELKORN, DAVID F. & GERMAE K. 24139 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
FIEBELKORN, DAVID F. & GERMAE K. 5355 DEER CROSSING SHEFFIELD LAKE, OH 44054

204-25-831C 5500 R 23012 ROBERT’S RUN 90 04/02/14 0 .000 Y 1
MILLER, MARK WARRANTY D FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI 168,400
639015 Lnd: 18,700 Bld: 168,400 Tot: 187,100
MILLER, MARK 23012 ROBERT’S RUN 90 BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MILLER, MARK 23012 ROBERT’S RUN UNIT 90 BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-25-833C 5500 R 23008 ROBERT’S RUN 92 04/24/14 190,000 1.020 Y 1
ROBERT’S RUN 4647, LLC TRUSTEE LINDWAY, NORMAN J. & REBECCA K. TRS 174,400
642225 302285 Lnd: 19,400 Bld: 174,400 Tot: 193,800
ROBERT’S RUN 4647, LLC 23008 ROBERT’S RUN 92 BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
ROBERT’S RUN 4647, LLC 344 HIGHLAND AVE WINCHESTER, MA 01890
Page 10

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

204-26-012 5100 R 23718 WOLF RD 04/07/14 0 .000 Y 1
FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI SHERIFFS D GRAY, THOMAS 89,800
639518 Lnd: 32,200 Bld: 89,800 Tot: 122,000
FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI 23718 WOLF RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI PO BOX 650043 DALLAS, TX 75265
Total Number of Parcels: 59 Total Sales -10.00
Page 11

Sales File Validation

Sales Listing

BAY VILLAGE
Sales From: 2014-05-01 To 2014-05-31

Certified Year: 2013

Parcel Year: 2014

Run Date: 6/3/2014

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

201-10-019 5100 R 31201 ROXBURY PARK DR 05/30/14 339,900 1.390 Y 1
PIERCE, BYRON AND REAPE, ANN E SURVIVORSH DIGIOVANNI, SUE & MADDEN, SARA & KI 389,700
647703 304980 Lnd: 82,200 Bld: 389,700 Tot: 471,900
PIERCE, BYRON AND REAPE, ANN E 31201 ROXBURY PARK DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
PIERCE, BYRON AND REAPE, ANN E 31201 ROXBURY PARK DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-13-009 5100 R 00274 BRADLEY RD 05/01/14 130,000 1.290 Y 1
BRUNER, MICHAEL AND JACQUELINE SURVIVORSH PETRIGAC LINDA J 134,100
643385 302935 Lnd: 33,300 Bld: 134,100 Tot: 167,400
MICHAEL BRUNER 00274 BRADLEY RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MICHAEL BRUNER 274 BRADLEY ROAD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-15-030 5100 R 31417 BEXLEY DR 05/13/14 0 .000 Y 1
WEILAND, FREDERICK LEO AFFIDAVIT VYSOCKY, MARY LOU & WEILAND, FREDER 116,300
645005 Lnd: 47,000 Bld: 116,300 Tot: 163,300
WEILAND, FREDERICK LEO 31417 BEXLEY DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
WEILAND, FREDERICK LEO 31417 BEXLEY DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-16-016 5100 R 31017 BEXLEY DR 05/06/14 159,500 .950 Y 1
DEROOVER KUMLER, AMY WARRANTY D HAM DEREK C. & HAM JENNIFER A. 120,400
643971 303223 Lnd: 30,800 Bld: 120,400 Tot: 151,200
DEROOVER KUMLER, AMY 31017 BEXLEY DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DEROOVER KUMLER, AMY 800 W ST CLAIR CLEVELAND, OH 44113
Page 1

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

201-18-039 5100 R 31022 CLAREWOOD DR 05/13/14 0 .000 Y 1
GALDUN, BARBARA A AFFIDAVIT GARY A & BARBARA A GALDUN 198,500
645017 Lnd: 48,300 Bld: 198,500 Tot: 246,800
GALDUN, BARBARA A 31022 CLAREWOOD DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
GALDUN, BARBARA A 31022 CLAREWOOD DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-19-007 5100 R 00410 WALMAR DR 05/28/14 315,000 .720 Y 1
KLOSTERMAN, KRISTIN M. & JASON T. SURVIVORSH WOCHNA, CHARLES F 181,000
647204 304699 Lnd: 45,100 Bld: 181,000 Tot: 226,100
KLOSTERMAN, KRISTIN M. 00410 WALMAR DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
KLOSTERMAN, KRISTIN M. 410 WALMAR DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-27-012 5100 R 31231 ROBERTA DR 05/20/14 272,000 .860 Y 1
EGGERS, ANDREW AND DANA SURVIVORSH FITZPATRICK, REGAN C. & SHANE M. 186,800
646116 304137 Lnd: 47,400 Bld: 186,800 Tot: 234,200
EGGERS, ANDREW AND DANA 31231 ROBERTA DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
EGGERS, ANDREW AND DANA 31231 ROBERTA DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-04-005 5100 R 28950 LAKE RD 05/23/14 0 .000 Y 1
MANRODT, WILLIAM H. & BONNIE L. TRU WARRANTY D MANRODT WILLIAM H 403,400
646646 Lnd: 300,800 Bld: 403,400 Tot: 704,200
MANRODT, WILLIAM H. 28950 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MANRODT, WILLIAM H. 28950 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-12-009 5100 R 28917 WESTWOOD RD 05/23/14 94,000 2.030 Y 1
CRAIG, CLAUDIA T WARRANTY D CRAIG, CLAUDIA T AND HEINICKE, KIMB 146,200
646627 304394 Lnd: 45,000 Bld: 146,200 Tot: 191,200
CRAIG, CLAUDIA T 28917 WESTWOOD RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
CRAIG, CLAUDIA T 12920 MC COY RD HUNTERSVILLE, NC 28078

202-12-033 5100 R 28925 WAYSIDE LN 05/13/14 0 .000 Y 1
COMERICA BANK & TRUST NA SUC TRS AFFIDAVIT KIDWELL, GUY S (TRS) 197,600
644994 Lnd: 72,100 Bld: 197,600 Tot: 269,700
COMERICA BANK & TRUST NA SUC TRS 28925 WAYSIDE LN BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
COMERICA BANK & TRUST NA SUC TRS PO BOX 75000 DETROIT, MI 48275
Page 2

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

202-20-034 5100 R 30108 CRESTVIEW DR 05/15/14 235,000 .970 Y 1
BROWN, PETER L. WARRANTY D HOPKINS, CHRISTOPHER J. 184,100
645456 303805 Lnd: 42,800 Bld: 184,100 Tot: 226,900
BROWN, PETER L. 30108 CRESTVIEW DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
BROWN, PETER L. 30108 CRESTVIEW DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-23-018 5100 R 29620 OSBORN RD 05/16/14 215,000 .830 Y 1
LINTERMOOT, KASEY L. WARRANTY D GILLETTE, BRYAN R. & EMILY J. 132,800
645846 304010 Lnd: 44,700 Bld: 132,800 Tot: 177,500
LINTERMOOT, KASEY L. 29620 OSBORN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
LINTERMOOT, KASEY L. 29620 OSBORN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-25-049 5100 R 29248 COWLES DR 05/06/14 485,000 .930 Y 1
FITZPATRICK, SHANE M & FITZPATRICK, SURVIVORSH ROUBAL, THOMAS A. 395,600
643994 303237 Lnd: 56,300 Bld: 395,600 Tot: 451,900
FITZPATRICK, SHANE M 29248 COWLES DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
FITZPATRICK, SHANE M 29248 COWLES DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-26-007 5100 R 28928 OSBORN RD 05/15/14 125,000 1.360 Y 1
DAN RICH LLC WARRANTY D ONEWEST BANK FSB 121,600
645485 303821 Lnd: 48,600 Bld: 121,600 Tot: 170,200
DAN RICH LLC 28928 OSBORN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DAN RICH LLC 23425 COMMERCE PARK DR SUITE 102 BEACHWOOD, OH 44122

202-29-042 5100 R 28309 LINCOLN RD 05/09/14 329,500 .710 Y 1
GOOD, DARCY MEHLING WARRANTY D HULL, JOHN C & MARY JANE P. 189,800
644663 303514 Lnd: 45,600 Bld: 189,800 Tot: 235,400
GOOD, DARCY MEHLING 28309 LINCOLN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
GOOD, DARCY MEHLING 28309 LINCOLN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-30-015 5100 R 28514 OVIATT RD 05/23/14 235,000 .840 Y 1
STREICHER, DAYNA L. & GEOFFREY R. SURVIVORSH KRAJCIK, MATTHEW R. & STEPHANIE T. 151,900
646719 304425 Lnd: 45,100 Bld: 151,900 Tot: 197,000
STREICHER, DAYNA L. 28514 OVIATT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
STREICHER, DAYNA L. 28514 OVIATT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 3

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

202-34-003 5100 R 29815 OSBORN RD 05/06/14 0 .000 Y 1
FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI SHERIFFS D FOX, DALE R. 162,500
643891 Lnd: 35,400 Bld: 162,500 Tot: 197,900
FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI 29815 OSBORN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI PO BOX 650043 DALLAS, TX 75265

203-03-057 5100 R 28001 OAKLAND RD 05/06/14 422,000 .580 Y 3
PUTERBAUGH, KIM M. WARRANTY D DANIELSON, BRACKEN M. 211,200
643922 303198 Lnd: 31,900 Bld: 211,200 Tot: 243,100
PUTERBAUGH, KIM M. 28001 OAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
PUTERBAUGH, KIM M. 28001 WOAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-03-058 5000 R OAKLAND RD 05/06/14 422,000 .010 Y 3
PUTERBAUGH, KIM M. WARRANTY D DANIELSON, BRACKEN M. 0
643922 303198 Lnd: 6,300 Bld: 0 Tot: 6,300
PUTERBAUGH, KIM M. OAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
PUTERBAUGH, KIM M. 28001 WOAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-03-059 5000 R OAKLAND RD 05/06/14 422,000 .010 Y 3
PUTERBAUGH, KIM M. WARRANTY D DANIELSON, BRACKEN M. 0
643922 303198 Lnd: 3,700 Bld: 0 Tot: 3,700
PUTERBAUGH, KIM M. OAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
PUTERBAUGH, KIM M. 28001 WOAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-08-021 5100 R 27852 ABERDEEN AVE 05/16/14 0 .000 Y 1
PAILES, RICHARD E. & NANCY J. RENTAL DIS PAILES, RICHARD E. & NANCY J. 97,100
645650 Lnd: 25,700 Bld: 97,100 Tot: 122,800
RICHARD E PAILES 27852 ABERDEEN AVE BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
RICHARD E PAILES 30540 MANHASSET DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-11-044 5100 R 27430 DONALD AVE 05/08/14 137,000 1.070 Y 1
SMOTZER, CRAIG WARRANTY D NOBLE, MICHAEL P. 104,400
644451 303413 Lnd: 41,700 Bld: 104,400 Tot: 146,100
SMOTZER, CRAIG 27430 DONALD AVE BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SMOTZER, CRAIG 27430 DONALD AVE BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 4

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

203-19-064 5100 R 27025 OSBORN RD 05/16/14 224,900 .870 Y 1
SIRCHIA, ROBERT A AND ANITA SURVIVORSH WOLAN, THOMAS J & JAMES R 160,400
645668 303904 Lnd: 35,300 Bld: 160,400 Tot: 195,700
SIRCHIA, ROBERT A AND ANITA 27025 OSBORN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SIRCHIA, ROBERT A AND ANITA 27025 OSBORN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-23-028 5100 R 26818 KNICKERBOCKER RD 05/13/14 0 .000 Y 1
MONGER WEARSCH, SUSAN J ET AL AFFIDAVIT MONGER, JANE E. 84,700
645115 Lnd: 33,900 Bld: 84,700 Tot: 118,600
MONGER WEARSCH, SUSAN J ET AL 26818 KNICKERBOCKER RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MONGER WEARSCH, SUSAN J ET AL 26818 KNICKERBOCKER RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-26-082 5100 R 00562 KENILWORTH RD 05/09/14 100,000 .970 Y 1
SHOAFF, STUART R. & SHOAFF, LINDA J SURVIVORSH LAURI LEE’S PROPERTIES, LLC 70,000
644608 303489 Lnd: 26,700 Bld: 70,000 Tot: 96,700
SHOAFF, STUART R. 00562 KENILWORTH RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SHOAFF, STUART R. 562 KENILWORTH RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-28-040 5100 R 00357 CANTERBURY RD 05/21/14 180,000 .810 Y 2
EHMER, MATTHEW AND EHMER, ARIANNA SURVIVORSH DYKO LEONARD E & LUCY 120,300
646372 304260 Lnd: 25,900 Bld: 120,300 Tot: 146,200
EHMER, MATTHEW AND EHMER, ARIANNA 00357 CANTERBURY RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
EHMER, MATTHEW AND EHMER, ARIANNA 357 CANTERBURY RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-28-041 5000 R 00357 CANTERBURY RD 05/21/14 180,000 .070 Y 2
EHMER, MATTHEW AND EHMER, ARIANNA SURVIVORSH DYKO LEONARD E & LUCY 0
646372 304260 Lnd: 12,700 Bld: 0 Tot: 12,700
EHMER, MATTHEW AND EHMER, ARIANNA 00357 CANTERBURY RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
EHMER, MATTHEW AND EHMER, ARIANNA 357 CANTERBURY RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-28-045 5100 R 00337 CANTERBURY RD 05/28/14 174,500 .870 Y 1
BAIRD, MATTHEW G. & DANA L. WARRANTY D MILLER, RHONDA A 126,700
647155 304661 Lnd: 25,900 Bld: 126,700 Tot: 152,600
BAIRD, MATTHEW G. & DANA L. 00337 CANTERBURY RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
BAIRD, MATTHEW G. & DANA L. 7007 BROADWAY AVE CLEVELAND, OH 44105
Page 5

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

203-28-065b> 5100 R 00401 ELMWOOD RD 05/23/14 187,000 .880 Y 1
EFFERTH, SCOTT & BACKUS, SUSAN E. SURVIVORSH ROX, ETHAN W. & LINDSAY J. 138,700
646727 304434 Lnd: 25,900 Bld: 138,700 Tot: 164,600
EFFERTH, SCOTT 00401 ELMWOOD RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
EFFERTH, SCOTT 401 ELMWOOD RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-29-004 5100 R 00297 GLEN PARK DR 05/27/14 0 .000 Y 1
SECRETARY OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVE WARRANTY D NATIONWIDE ADVANTAGE MORTGAGE COMPA 105,700
646861 Lnd: 32,300 Bld: 105,700 Tot: 138,000
SECRETARY OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVE 00297 GLEN PARK DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SECRETARY OF HOUSING AND URBAN DEVE 3 ADVANTAGE CT BORDENTOWN, NJ 08505

203-30-040 5100 R 00595 PARKSIDE DR 05/20/14 0 .000 Y 1
GOERZ, ELYNORE B AFFIDAVIT GOERZ ROBERT J & ELYNORE B 98,700
646208 Lnd: 26,800 Bld: 98,700 Tot: 125,500
GOERZ, ELYNORE B 00595 PARKSIDE DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
GOERZ, ELYNORE B 21300 LORAIN DR FAIRVIEW PARK , OH 44126

203-30-067 5100 R 25815 EATON WAY 05/27/14 315,000 .310 Y 1
LAURIO, STEPHEN WARRANTY D EQUITY TRUST CUSTODIAN 67,700
646942 304555 Lnd: 29,300 Bld: 67,700 Tot: 97,000
LAURIO, STEPHEN 25815 EATON WAY BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
LAURIO, STEPHEN 25815 EATON WAY BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-30-080 5100 R 00569 HUNTMERE RD 05/30/14 140,000 .950 Y 1
VLEUGELS, MARK A WARRANTY D BITTINGER, STEPHEN D. & JENNIFER A. 102,100
647701 304979 Lnd: 30,600 Bld: 102,100 Tot: 132,700
VLEUGELS, MARK A 00569 HUNTMERE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
VLEUGELS, MARK A 569 HUNTMERE DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-01-022 5100 R 00586 LAKE FOREST DR 05/12/14 0 .000 Y 1
WIRTZ, JOHN V AND AMY Y – TRUSTEE QUIT CLAIM WIRTZ, JOHN V 175,300
644881 Lnd: 32,000 Bld: 175,300 Tot: 207,300
JOHN V AND MAY Y WITRZ – TRUSTEE 00586 LAKE FOREST DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
JOHN V AND MAY Y WITRZ – TRUSTEE 586 LAKE FOREST DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140-2513
Page 6

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

204-01-107 5100 R 00617 COLUMBIA RD 05/21/14 84,000 1.410 Y 1
BERRY, BRIAN & BERRY, SUSAN S. SURVIVORSH SADLOWSKI, GERALD 92,600
646402 304278 Lnd: 25,500 Bld: 92,600 Tot: 118,100
BERRY, BRIAN 00617 COLUMBIA RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
BERRY, BRIAN 617 COLUMBIA RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-03-003 5100 R 00447 OAKMOOR AVE 05/13/14 0 .000 Y 1
RILEY, MARLENE E AFFIDAVIT RILEY, DONALD F & MARLENE E 138,900
645023 Lnd: 26,100 Bld: 138,900 Tot: 165,000
RILEY, MARLENE E 00447 OAKMOOR AVE BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
RILEY, MARLENE E 601 CENTER CT AVON LAKE, OH 44012

204-05-026 5100 R 25217 BAYFAIR CT 05/23/14 0 .000 Y 1
EATON, SCOTT C AFFIDAVIT EATON, SCOTT C. 115,300
646826 Lnd: 27,200 Bld: 115,300 Tot: 142,500
VLCEK, JOSEPH RONALD 25217 BAYFAIR CT BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
VLCEK, JOSEPH RONALD 25217 BAYFAIR CT BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-05-026 5100 R 25217 BAYFAIR CT 05/23/14 118,000 1.210 Y 1
VLCEK, JOSEPH RONALD WARRANTY D EATON, SCOTT C 115,300
646827 304503 Lnd: 27,200 Bld: 115,300 Tot: 142,500
VLCEK, JOSEPH RONALD 25217 BAYFAIR CT BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
VLCEK, JOSEPH RONALD 25217 BAYFAIR CT BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-10-033 5100 R 00580 VINELAND RD 05/12/14 34,500 2.360 Y 1
THE HUNTINGTON NATIONAL BANK SHERIFFS D WAGNER, KEVIN C. 55,700
644752 303559 Lnd: 25,800 Bld: 55,700 Tot: 81,500
THE HUNTINGTON NATIONAL BANK 00580 VINELAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
THE HUNTINGTON NATIONAL BANK 2361 MORSE RD COLUMBUS, OH 43229

204-10-058 5100 R 24925 FORESTVIEW RD 05/23/14 0 .000 Y 1
DORSEY, KIMBERLY S. & JOSEPH E. SURVIVORSH DORSEY, KIMBERLY S. 105,100
646740 Lnd: 27,100 Bld: 105,100 Tot: 132,200
DORSEY, KIMBERLY S. 24925 FORESTVIEW RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DORSEY, KIMBERLY S. 14724 FERNWAY AVE CLEVELAND, OH 44111
Page 7

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

204-17-019 5100 R 00417 VINELAND RD 05/07/14 0 .000 Y 1
SIMOLIN, STEFANIE M (NKA FYFE, STEF QUIT CLAIM SIMOLIN, MICHAEL J. 105,300
644068 Lnd: 36,200 Bld: 105,300 Tot: 141,500
SIMOLIN, STEFANIE M (NKA FYFE, STEF 00417 VINELAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SIMOLIN, STEFANIE M (NKA FYFE, STEF 417 VINELAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-22-010 5100 R 23904 LAKE RD 05/06/14 174,000 .740 Y 1
MCCLAIN, PATRICK C & WALSH-MATIA, M SURVIVORSH STEINWASCHER, KURT F. TRUSTEE 88,900
643965 303220 Lnd: 39,700 Bld: 88,900 Tot: 128,600
MCCLAIN, PATRICK C & 23904 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MCCLAIN, PATRICK C & 800 W ST CLAIR CLEVELAND, OH 44113

204-23-072 5100 R 23533 LAKE RD 05/30/14 196,000 .480 Y 1
KRAFT, LORA L. WARRANTY D PITFA PROPERTIES, LLC 60,900
647579 304898 Lnd: 32,600 Bld: 60,900 Tot: 93,500
KRAFT, LORA L. 23533 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
KRAFT, LORA L. P O BOX 16674 ROCKY RIVER, OH 44116-0674

204-24-826C 5500 R 23200 LAKE RD 30 05/14/14 188,000 .960 Y 1
LEISSA, ANN MARIE WARRANTY D BROWN, RICHARD G. 162,200
645242 303746 Lnd: 18,000 Bld: 162,200 Tot: 180,200
LEISSA, ANN MARIE 23200 LAKE RD 30 BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
LEISSA, ANN MARIE 4820 EASTGATE MALL SQ SUITE 100 SAN DIEGO, CA 92121

204-27-015 5100 R 23111 LINCOLNSHIRE DR 05/05/14 203,000 .750 Y 1
KILBANE, SHANNON & MCDONNELL, ROBER SURVIVORSH COTICCHIA, DEAN A 115,900
643778 303114 Lnd: 36,100 Bld: 115,900 Tot: 152,000
KILBANE, SHANNON 23111 LINCOLNSHIRE DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
KILBANE, SHANNON 23111 LINCOLNSHIRE DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-27-024 5100 R 23313 LINCOLNSHIRE DR 05/19/14 150,000 1.040 Y 1
DABROWSKI, ROBERT JR. AND DABROWSKI SURVIVORSH HORTON, THERESA LOUISE 118,500
645933 304062 Lnd: 37,600 Bld: 118,500 Tot: 156,100
DABROWSKI, ROBERT JR. AND DABROWSKI 23313 LINCOLNSHIRE DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DABROWSKI, ROBERT JR. AND DABROWSKI 23313 LINCOLNSHIRE DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 8

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

204-28-023 5100 R 00628 HUMISTON DR 05/09/14 168,000 .840 Y 1
BAKER, CHAD W. WARRANTY D CAMPBELL, DEVON R. 115,700
644589 303477 Lnd: 24,600 Bld: 115,700 Tot: 140,300
BAKER, CHAD W. 00628 HUMISTON DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
BAKER, CHAD W. 628 HUMISTON DR BAYVILLAGE, OH 44140

204-28-033 5100 R 00577 HUMISTON DR 05/20/14 0 .000 Y 1
HARTZELL JENNIFER WARRANTY D HARTZELL, CHRISTOPHER T 183,000
646177 304154 Lnd: 27,200 Bld: 183,000 Tot: 210,200
HARTZELL JENNIFER 00577 HUMISTON DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
HARTZELL JENNIFER 577 HUMINSTON DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Total Number of Parcels: 48 Total Sales -8.00
Page 9

Sales File Validation

Sales Listing

BAY VILLAGE
Sales From: 2014-06-01 To 2014-06-30

Certified Year: 2013

Parcel Year: 2014

Run Date: 7/1/2014

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

201-05-018 5100 R 30663 LAKE RD 06/30/14 0 .000 Y 1
GRAHAM, SCOTT A. & SUZANNE CAWRSE ( WARRANTY D GRAHAM, SCOTT A/td>

234,600
652376 Lnd: 61,700 Bld: 234,600 Tot: 296,300
GRAHAM, SCOTT A. & SUZANNE CAWRSE ( 30663 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
GRAHAM, SCOTT A. & SUZANNE CAWRSE ( 30663 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-05-035 5100 R 00175 BRADLEY RD 06/19/14 0 .000 Y 1
MARIANI, ROGER V. & SUSAN J. (CO-T QUIT CLAIM MARIANI, SUSAN J. TRUSTEE 161,400
650799 Lnd: 45,000 Bld: 161,400 Tot: 206,400
MARIANI, ROGER V. 00175 BRADLEY RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MARIANI, ROGER V. 175 BRADLEY RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-06-034 5100 R 30401 LAKE RD 06/27/14 405,000 .820 Y 1
MARUNA, JOHN P & MARUNA, MONA E SURVIVORSH WARD, JAMES & JAYME 281,300
652113 307043 Lnd: 51,200 Bld: 281,300 Tot: 332,500
MARUNA, JOHN P 30401 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MARUNA, JOHN P 30401 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-08-028 5100 R 00291 BAY VIEW RD 06/16/14 217,900 .760 Y 1
HOLUP, BRYAN J. AND HOLUP, VIRGINIA SURVIVORSH CORN, JOHN C & TERRA J 132,300
650193 306131 Lnd: 33,200 Bld: 132,300 Tot: 165,500
HOLUP, BRYAN J. AND HOLUP, VIRGINIA 00291 BAY VIEW RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
HOLUP, BRYAN J. AND HOLUP, VIRGINIA 291 BAY VIEW RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 1

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

201-08-043 5100 R 00312 BASSETT RD 06/13/14 0 .000 Y 1
MCBRIDE, NANCY G. QUIT CLAIM MCBRIDE GERALD A 124,700
649920 Lnd: 31,700 Bld: 124,700 Tot: 156,400
MCBRIDE, NANCY G. 00312 BASSETT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MCBRIDE, NANCY G. 312 BASSETT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-12-025 5100 R 00206 PLYMOUTH DR 06/06/14 0 .000 Y 1
WILLIAMS, CHRISTOPHER I. & STACY L. WARRANTY D WILLIAMS, CHRISTOPHER I. & STACY L. 230,800
648689 Lnd: 76,400 Bld: 230,800 Tot: 307,200
WILLIAMS, CHRISTOPHER I. 00206 PLYMOUTH DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
WILLIAMS, CHRISTOPHER I. 206 PLYMOUTH DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-17-031 5100 R 30828 CARLTON DR 06/19/14 147,000 .880 Y 1
EGBERT, ADAM B & WEBER, ELIZABETH R SURVIVORSH PENNOCK, SCOTT M. 103,400
650897 306461 Lnd: 26,400 Bld: 103,400 Tot: 129,800
EGBERT, ADAM B & WEBER, ELIZABETH R 30828 CARLTON DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
EGBERT, ADAM B & WEBER, ELIZABETH R 800 WST CLAIR AVE CLEVELAND, OH 44113

201-18-015 5100 R 00409 PELLETT DR 06/27/14 0 .000 Y 1
HIRT, EDWARD K. SUC TRS AFFIDAVIT HIRT, HAROLD K. TRS 191,300
652158 Lnd: 50,400 Bld: 191,300 Tot: 241,700
HIRT, EDWARD K. 00409 PELLETT DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
HIRT, EDWARD K. 409 PELLET DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-18-015 5100 R 00409 PELLETT DR 06/27/14 0 .000 Y 1
HIRT, EDWARD K. QUIT CLAIM HIRT, EDWARD K. SUC TRS 191,300
652159 Lnd: 50,400 Bld: 191,300 Tot: 241,700
HIRT, EDWARD K. 00409 PELLETT DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
HIRT, EDWARD K. 409 PELLET DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-25-031 5100 R 31401 MARVIS DR 06/06/14 0 .000 Y 1
ULE, CAROL ANN- TRUSTEE QUIT CLAIM ULE, CAROL A. 192,600
648772 Lnd: 53,000 Bld: 192,600 Tot: 245,600
ULE, CAROL ANN- TRUSTEE 31401 MARVIS DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
ULE, CAROL ANN- TRUSTEE 31401 MARVIS DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 2

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

201-30-012 5100 R 30501 WINSOR DR 06/30/14 350,000 .910 Y 1
WILK, MARISSA L. WARRANTY D STAN, WILLIAM STEVEN 261,700
652426 307231 Lnd: 55,400 Bld: 261,700 Tot: 317,100
WILK, MARISSA L. 30501 WINSOR DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
WILK, MARISSA L. 30501 WINSOR DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-31-008 5100 R 00304 SADDLER RD 06/02/14 0 .000 Y 1
MORAN, JEFFREY J. (TRUSTEE) QUIT CLAIM MORAN, CYNTHIA S 176,900
647933 Lnd: 42,500 Bld: 176,900 Tot: 219,400
MORAN, JEFFREY J. (TRUSTEE) 00304 SADDLER RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MORAN, JEFFREY J. (TRUSTEE) 304 SADDLER RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

201-36-022 5100 R 30229 WESTLAWN DR 06/10/14 150,000 .940 Y 1
LACKEY, COLIN D. AND BRAY, JILLIAN SURVIVORSH BEERMAN, MARTIN H. 116,000
649156 305620 Lnd: 24,300 Bld: 116,000 Tot: 140,300
LACKEY, COLIN D. AND BRAY, JILLIAN 30229 WESTLAWN DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
LACKEY, COLIN D. AND BRAY, JILLIAN 30229 WESTLAWN DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-06-009 5100 R 00353 BASSETT RD 06/04/14 172,000 1.030 Y 1
SCHMIDT, LAURA M. WARRANTY D BEICKE, KELLY 154,700
648301 305285 Lnd: 22,200 Bld: 154,700 Tot: 176,900
SCHMIDT, LAURA M. 00353 BASSETT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SCHMIDT, LAURA M. 353 BASSET RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-06-026 5100 R 29711 FOOTE AVE 06/18/14 0 .000 Y 1
IJMS OHIO, LLC QUIT CLAIM MAYBAUM, DIANE & MICHAEL 108,500
650601 Lnd: 27,600 Bld: 108,500 Tot: 136,100
IJMS OHIO, LLC 29711 FOOTE AVE BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
IJMS OHIO, LLC 29721 FOOTE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-15-019 5100 R 30341 PROVINCETOWN LN 06/17/14 320,000 .700 Y 1
LAMB, ANDREW T JR & LAMB, NORA SURVIVORSH GREALIS ROBERT F 180,500
650422 306272 Lnd: 42,600 Bld: 180,500 Tot: 223,100
LAMB, ANDREW T JR & LAMB, NORA 30341 PROVINCETOWN LN BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
LAMB, ANDREW T JR & LAMB, NORA 501 CORPORATE CENTRE #400 FRANKLIN, TN 37067
Page 3

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

202-16-811C 5500 R 30651 CAMBRIDGE CIR 13 06/24/14 0 .000 Y 1
ROWLAND, BILLY S. – TRUSTEE & FAY R LAND CONTR ROWLAND, BILLY S. – TRUSTEE & FAY R 116,100
651431 Lnd: 12,900 Bld: 116,100 Tot: 129,000
ROWLAND, BILLY S. – TRUSTEE 30651 CAMBRIDGE CIR 13 BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
ROWLAND, BILLY S. – TRUSTEE 30651 CAMBRIDGE CIR UNIT 13 BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-16-813C 5500 R 30611 CAMBRIDGE DR 19-6 06/30/14 128,000 1.000 Y 1
MARKIOLI, SANDRA M WARRANTY D PUSZTAI, JOHN A. 115,600
652523 307297 Lnd: 12,800 Bld: 115,600 Tot: 128,400
MARKIOLI, SANDRA M 30611 CAMBRIDGE DR 19-6 BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MARKIOLI, SANDRA M 30611 CAMBRIDGE CIR Unit 19 BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-16-822C 5500 R 30683 CAMBRIDGE W CT 5-2 06/30/14 0 .000 Y 1
BENINGHOF, RICHARD D. QUIT CLAIM BENINGHOF, VIRGINIA E. 117,800
652423 Lnd: 13,100 Bld: 117,800 Tot: 130,900
BENINGHOF, RICHARD D. 30683 CAMBRIDGE W CT 5-2 BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
BENINGHOF, RICHARD D. 30683 CAMBRIDGE CT Unit 5-2 BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-16-822C 5500 R 30683 CAMBRIDGE W CT 5-2 06/30/14 0 .000 Y 1
BENINGHOF, VIRGINIA E. AFFIDAVIT BENINGHOF, RICHARD M. & VIRGINIA E. 117,800
652421 Lnd: 13,100 Bld: 117,800 Tot: 130,900
BENINGHOF, RICHARD D. 30683 CAMBRIDGE W CT 5-2 BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
BENINGHOF, RICHARD D. 30683 CAMBRIDGE CT Unit 5-2 BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-30-023 5100 R 28405 OVIATT RD 06/16/14 274,900 .740 Y 1
FRY, MICHAEL & ANGELA SURVIVORSH EVANOFF ERIC B 158,000
650225 306153 Lnd: 44,300 Bld: 158,000 Tot: 202,300
FRY, MICHAEL 28405 OVIATT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
FRY, MICHAEL 28405 OVIATT RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-33-009 5100 R 29075 OSBORN RD 06/12/14 215,000 1.000 Y 1
CORN, JOHN CLARK WARRANTY D CLARK, MARY H. 163,400
649661 305858 Lnd: 51,600 Bld: 163,400 Tot: 215,000
CORN, JOHN CLARK 29075 OSBORN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
CORN, JOHN CLARK 291 BAYVIEW RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 4

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

202-34-068 5100 R 00588 MARYGATE DR 06/25/14 353,000 .740 Y 1
BINGAMAN, JOHN R. & HEATHER W. SURVIVORSH MARUNA, JOHN P. & MONA E. 214,800
651685 306862 Lnd: 47,800 Bld: 214,800 Tot: 262,600
BINGAMAN, JOHN R. 00588 MARYGATE DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
BINGAMAN, JOHN R. 588 MARYGATE DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-35-008 5100 R 29123 MILLARD DR 06/17/14 262,000 .850 Y 1
BURGER, BRIAN F. & COURTNEY SURVIVORSH SNOW, DANIEL C. 178,200
650400 306248 Lnd: 44,600 Bld: 178,200 Tot: 222,800
BURGER, BRIAN F. 29123 MILLARD DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
BURGER, BRIAN F. 29123 MILLARD DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

202-36-046 5100 R 29630 NORFOLK DR 06/18/14 0 .000 Y 1
CORSARO, MEAGAN E. (TRUSTEE) QUIT CLAIM CORSARO, JOSEPH M. & MEAGAN 175,500
650671 Lnd: 50,100 Bld: 175,500 Tot: 225,600
CORSARO, MEAGAN E. (TRUSTEE) 29630 NORFOLK DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
CORSARO, MEAGAN E. (TRUSTEE) 29630 NORFOLK DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-03-040 5100 R 27916 OAKLAND RD 06/11/14 215,000 1.020 Y 2
DURK, JAMES A WARRANTY D DURK, JAMES A 191,200
649465 305770 Lnd: 29,000 Bld: 191,200 Tot: 220,200
DURK, JAMES A 27916 OAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DURK, JAMES A 27916 OAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-03-040 5100 R 27916 OAKLAND RD 06/11/14 215,000 1.020 Y 2
DURK, JAMES A WARRANTY D MCGETTRICK, MICHAEL A & KING, KRIST 191,200

td width=10%>

649462 305769 Lnd: 29,000 Bld: 191,200 Tot: 220,200
DURK, JAMES A 27916 OAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DURK, JAMES A 27916 OAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-03-041 5000 R 27916 OAKLAND RD 06/11/14 215,000 .010 Y 2
/b> MCGETTRICK, MICHAEL A & KING, KRIST WARRANTY D MCGETTRICK, MICHAEL A & KING, KRIST 0
649462 305769 Lnd: 2,900 Bld: 0 Tot: 2,900
DURK, JAMES A 27916 OAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DURK, JAMES A 27916 OAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 5

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

203-03-041 5000 R 27916 OAKLAND RD 06/11/14 215,000 .010 Y 2
DURK, JAMES A WARRANTY D MCGETTRICK, MICHAEL A & KING, KRIST 0
649465 305770 Lnd: 2,900 Bld: 0 Tot: 2,900
DURK, JAMES A 27916 OAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DURK, JAMES A 27916 OAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-03-081 5100 R 28028 OSBORN RD 06/13/14 130,000 .940 Y 1
DIPERT, BRADLEY T. & KRISTEN M. SURVIVORSH NAUGHTON, MICHAEL T & RUSTY TRUSTEE 86,700
649918 305985 Lnd: 35,700 Bld: 86,700 Tot: 122,400
DIPERT, BRADLEY T. 28028 OSBORN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DIPERT, BRADLEY T. 28028 OSBORN RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-04-011 5100 R 27853 OAKLAND RD 06/13/14 0 .000 Y 1
FALCONE, NICK M. AFFIDAVIT FALCONE NICK M & CAROL D 114,500
649852 Lnd: 28,200 Bld: 114,500 Tot: 142,700
FALCONE, NICK M. 27853 OAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
FALCONE, NICK M. 27853 OAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-08-019 5100 R 27842 ABERDEEN AVE 06/30/14 118,000 .660 Y 1
GREULICH, JOYCE A WARRANTY D HOMES, THOMAS A. 51,700
652497 307274 Lnd: 25,700 Bld: 51,700 Tot: 77,400
GREULICH, JOYCE A 27842 ABERDEEN AVE BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
GREULICH, JOYCE A 27842 ABERDEEN AVE BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-08-045 5100 R 27831 REXFORD AVE 06/19/14 199,000 .690 Y 1
WALLACE, ELIZABETH M WARRANTY D WARDEN, JENNIFER K. 112,000
650801 306418 Lnd: 25,700 Bld: 112,000 Tot: 137,700
WALLACE, ELIZABETH M 27831 REXFORD AVE BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
WALLACE, ELIZABETH M 27831 REXFORD RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-08-064 5100 R 00620 CAHOON RD 06/27/14 0 .000 Y 1
font size=2>FARRELL, BETHANY J CORRECTIVE HAIGHT, BETHANY J 95,900
652037 Lnd: 30,500 Bld: 95,900 Tot: 126,400
FARRELL, BETHANY J 00620 CAHOON RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
FARRELL, BETHANY J 620 CAHOON RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 6

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

203-09-022 5100 R 00511 CAHOON RD 06/30/14 241,000 .830 Y 1
CORSON, MARK L AND TALANA MEI SURVIVORSH HOLZHAUER, JUERGEN & ALEXANDRA SEE 166,400
652496 307278 Lnd: 34,100 Bld: 166,400 Tot: 200,500
CORSON, MARK L AND TALANA MEI 00511 CAHOON RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
CORSON, MARK L AND TALANA MEI 511 CAHOON RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-20-097 5100 R 00534 DOUGLAS DR 06/23/14 150,000 .910 Y 1
WOCHNA, CHARLES F. & TERESA N. SURVIVORSH MULLER, CAROL. 102,500
651277 306653 Lnd: 34,300 Bld: 102,500 Tot: 136,800
WOCHNA, CHARLES F. 00534 DOUGLAS DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
WOCHNA, CHARLES F. 534 DOUGLAS DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-21-017 5100 R 26626 MIDLAND RD 06/27/14 202,000 .830 Y 1
MALIBU HOLDINGS LP WARRANTY D MENDEZ, CARLOS ALONSO MEDINA & KNIG 141,100
652211 307100 Lnd: 26,400 Bld: 141,100 Tot: 167,500
MALIBU HOLDINGS LP 26626 MIDLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MALIBU HOLDINGS LP 3029 PROSPECT AVE CLEVELAND, OH 44115

203-27-004 5100 R 00475 GLEN PARK DR 06/06/14 179,900 .940 Y 1
KIRSCH, SARAH C. WARRANTY D PORTMAN, KATHERINE A. 137,500
648773 305456 Lnd: 31,200 Bld: 137,500 Tot: 168,700
KIRSCH, SARAH C. 00475 GLEN PARK DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
KIRSCH, SARAH C. 475 GLEN PARK DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-27-058 5100 R 00424 ELMWOOD RD 06/06/14 100,000 1.120 Y 1
DRERUP, JEAN WARRANTY D FALK, BARBARA J 85,700
648879 305521 Lnd: 25,900 Bld: 85,700 Tot: 111,600
DRERUP, JEAN 00424 ELMWOOD RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DRERUP, JEAN 28462 STONEGATE CIR WESTLAKE, OH 44145

203-31-003 5100 R 00543 KENILWORTH RD 06/09/14 205,000 .790 Y 1
CZARNOTA, JACQUELINE R. WARRANTY D BERGGREN, KRISTIN N. 134,900
649085 305600 Lnd: 27,000 Bld: 134,900 Tot: 161,900
CZARNOTA, JACQUELINE R. 00543 KENILWORTH RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
CZARNOTA, JACQUELINE R. P O BOX 660278 DALLAS, TX 75266
Page 7

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn/font> Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

203-31-092 5100 R 00489 HUNTMERE RD /font> 06/23/14 0 .000 Y 1
WALKER, MILDRED J (AKA WALKER, MILD AFFIDAVIT WALKER GEO E & MILDRED G 85,400
651237 Lnd: 27,600 Bld: 85,400 Tot: 113,000
WALKER, TERRY G – TRUSTEE 00489 HUNTMERE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
WALKER, TERRY G – TRUSTEE 489 HUNTMERE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-31-092 5100 R 00489 HUNTMERE RD 06/23/14 0 .000 Y 1
WALKER, TERRY G – TRUSTEE QUIT CLAIM WALKER, MILDRED J (AKA WALKER, MILD 85,400
651238 Lnd: 27,600 Bld: 85,400 Tot: 113,000
WALKER, TERRY G – TRUSTEE 00489 HUNTMERE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
WALKER, TERRY G – TRUSTEE 489 HUNTMERE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-34-001 5100 R 00333 KENILWORTH RD 06/20/14 111,000 1.160 Y 1
MASLAR, JEANNE M AND EDWARD S SURVIVORSH DENG, BI & SONG, RUIXIN 101,400
650996 306497 Lnd: 27,000 Bld: 101,400 Tot: 128,400
MASLAR, JEANNE M AND EDWARD S 00333 KENILWORTH RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MASLAR, JEANNE M AND EDWARD S 333 KENILWORTH RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

203-34-033 5100 R 26019 LAKE RD 06/16/14 184,000 .900 Y 1
DEMARIA, ANTHONY M. AND DEMARIA, CA SURVIVORSH BILTMORE PROPERTIES & DEVELOPMENT L 135,000
650202 306137 Lnd: 29,700 Bld: 135,000 Tot: 164,700
DEMARIA, ANTHONY M. AND DEMARIA, CA 26019 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DEMARIA, ANTHONY M. AND DEMARIA, CA 26019 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-04-026 5100 R 25705 LAKE RD 06/30/14 0 .000 Y 1
font size=2>STAUSS, MICHAEL V. AND STAUSS, JENN SURVIVORSH STAUSS, MICHAEL V. 154,500
652349 Lnd: 33,400 Bld: 154,500 Tot: 187,900
STAUSS, MICHAEL V. AND STAUSS, JENN 25705 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
STAUSS, MICHAEL V. AND STAUSS, JENN 25705 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-06-056 5100td>

R 00501 BAYFAIR DR 06/13/14 135,000 .960 Y 1
LENCOSKI, HEIDI & EUANS, JOAN E. SURVIVORSH KETTREN, JAMES M. & TAYLOR-KETTREN, 101,400
649854 305948 Lnd: 27,800 Bld: 101,400 Tot: 129,200
LENCOSKI, HEIDI 00501 BAYFAIR DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
LENCOSKI, HEIDI 501 BAYFAIR DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Page 8

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

204-07-007 5100 R 00462 FORESTVIEW RD 06/25/14 189,900 .750 Y 1
GRAHAM, CRAIG WARRANTY D SLAYMAKER, JAMES H & KARLA E 104,900
651650 306839 Lnd: 36,800 Bld: 104,900 Tot: 141,700
GRAHAM, CRAIG 00462 FORESTVIEW RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
GRAHAM, CRAIG 462 FORESTVIEW RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-07-027 5100 R 25316 CONOVER DR 06/23/14 100,000 1.330 Y 1
MOUGIANIS, GUS WARRANTY D HAGGETT, ERIC 110,100
651236 306629 Lnd: 22,700 Bld: 110,100 Tot: 132,800
MOUGIANIS, GUS 25316 CONOVER DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MOUGIANIS, GUS 25316 CONOVER DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-09-011 5100 R 25098 LAKE RD 06/11/14 0 .000 Y 1
DERUBBA, DIANE QUIT CLAIM MCDONNELL, JOHN G. & DERUBBA, DIANE 137,300
649387 Lnd: 34,500 Bld: 137,300 Tot: 171,800
DERUBBA, DIANE 25098 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DERUBBA, DIANE 25098 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-09-011 5100 R 25098 LAKE RD 06/19/14 0 .000 Y 1
DERUBBA, DIANE REFILE DEE DERUBBA, DIANE 137,300
650832 Lnd: 34,500 Bld: 137,300 Tot: 171,800
DERUBBA, DIANE 25098 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DERUBBA, DIANE 25098 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-10-050 5000 R KNICKERBOCKER RD 06/27/14 0 .000 Y 1
DORSEY, KIMBERLY S. & JOSEPH E. SURVIVORSH DORSEY, KIMBERLY S. 0
652326 Lnd: 6,400 Bld: 0 Tot: 6,400
DORSEY, KIMBERLY S. KNICKERBOCKER RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DORSEY, KIMBERLY S. 14724 FERNWAY AVE CLEVELAND, OH 44111

204-10-050 5000 R KNICKERBOCKER RD 06/27/14 0 .000 Y 1
DORSEY, KIMBERLY S. PROBATE CO SULZMAN, MARTIN F. 0
652324 Lnd: 6,400 Bld: 0 Tot: 6,400
DORSEY, KIMBERLY S. KNICKERBOCKER RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DORSEY, KIMBERLY S. 14724 FERNWAY AVE CLEVELAND, OH 44111
Page 9

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

204-12-022 5100 R 24802 WOLF RD 06/18/14 177,000 .900 Y 1
DISTER, CARL J. AND DISTER, NOEMI SURVIVORSH R.L. 117,500
650597 306331 Lnd: 41,100 Bld: 117,500 Tot: 158,600
DISTER, CARL J. AND DISTER, NOEMI 24802 WOLF RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DISTER, CARL J. AND DISTER, NOEMI 24802 WOLF RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-13-028 5100 R 24720 ELECTRIC DR 06/24/14 0 .000 Y 1
MCDANIEL, JULIA F. TRUSTEE CORRECTIVE MCDANIEL, JULIA F. TRUSTEE 105,600
651357 Lnd: 46,900 Bld: 105,600 Tot: 152,500
MCDANIEL, JULIA F. TRUSTEE 24720 ELECTRIC DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MCDANIEL, JULIA F. TRUSTEE 24720 ELECTRIC DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-15-034 5100 R 24404 OAKLAND RD 06/10/14 0 .000 Y 1
LINZEK RE, LLC WARRANTY D LINDES, CONRAD & KUCZEK, JOAN C. 113,000
649278 Lnd: 27,000 Bld: 113,000 Tot: 140,000
LINZEK RE, LLC 24404 OAKLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
LINZEK RE, LLC 13375 OLD PLEASANT VALLEY RD MIDDLEBURG HTS, OH 44130

204-18-002 5100 R 24532 LAKE RD 06/30/14 1,350,000 .730 Y 1
PREMIER BANK & TRUST, NA TRUSTEE SCHAEDLER, COLLEEN L. TRS 704,800
652574 307337 Lnd: 282,200 Bld: 704,800 Tot: 987,000
PREMIER BANK & TRUST, NA 24532 LAKE RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
PREMIER BANK & TRUST, NA 6141 WHIPPLE AVE NORTH CANTON, OH 44720

204-19-098 5100 R 00561 UPLAND RD 06/11/14 0 .000 Y 1
KRUEGER, DAVID A QUIT CLAIM KRUEGER, DAVID A 183,000
649373 Lnd: 44,100 Bld: 183,000 Tot: 227,100
DAVID KRUEGER 00561 UPLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
DAVID KRUEGER 561 UPLAND RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-23-001 5000 R CLIFF DR 06/03/14 325,000 .340 Y 1
MALIBU HOLDINGS, L.P WARRANTY D GARVER, VIRGINIA 0
648101 305203 Lnd: 111,100 Bld: 0 Tot: 111,100
MALIBU HOLDINGS, L.P CLIFF DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
MALIBU HOLDINGS, L.P 3029 PROSPECT AVE CLEVELAND, OH 44115
Page 10

Parcel Luc Class Address Sale Date Sale Amount Ratio Valid NmPrp
Afn Grantee Deed Type Grantor Bld
InstmtNo CnvyNo RcptNo Cert Lnd Cert Bld Cert Tot
Physical Address
Mailing Address

204-24-022 5100 R 00457 DEVONSHIRE CT 06/10/14 0 .000 Y 1
SMITH, NANNETTE J. AFFIDAVIT SMITH JOHN C 176,700
649179 Lnd: 33,900 Bld: 176,700 Tot: 210,600
JONES, COLLEEN W. TRUSTEE 00457 DEVONSHIRE CT BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
JONES, COLLEEN W. TRUSTEE 457 DEVONSHIRE CT BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-24-022 5100 R 00457 DEVONSHIRE CT 06/10/14 0 .000 Y 1
JONES, COLLEEN W. TRUSTEE WARRANTY D SMITH, NANNETTE J. 176,700
649180 Lnd: 33,900 Bld: 176,700 Tot: 210,600
JONES, COLLEEN W. TRUSTEE 00457 DEVONSHIRE CT BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
JONES, COLLEEN W. TRUSTEE 457 DEVONSHIRE CT BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-25-032 5100 R 00469 SANDALWOOD DR 06/13/14 195,000 .730 Y 1
SISTO, PHILIP M. & SISTO, AMY E. SURVIVORSH BUDZ, JOESPH A. & ZABORNIAK, ANNE-F 108,000
650000 306040 Lnd: 34,500 Bld: 108,000 Tot: 142,500
SISTO, PHILIP M. 00469 SANDALWOOD DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
SISTO, PHILIP M. 469 SANDALWOOD DR BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-26-011 5100 R 23712 WOLF RD 06/13/14 0 .000 Y 1
WASSMER, DANIEL LIMITED WA FEDERAL NATIONAL MORTGAGE ASSOCIATI 113,500
649952 Lnd: 32,200 Bld: 113,500 Tot: 145,700
WASSMER, DANIEL 23712 WOLF RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
WASSMER, DANIEL 23712 WOLF RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140

204-26-023 5100 R 23715 WOLF RD 06/02/14 0 .000 Y 2
EDWARDS FINANCIAL GROUP, LLC , HALL GOVORNOR E EDWARDS FINANCIAL GROUP, LLC , HALL 33,000
647907 Lnd: 45,000 Bld: 33,000 Tot: 78,000
EDWARDS FINANCIAL GROUP, LLC 23715 WOLF RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
EDWARDS FINANCIAL GROUP, LLC 4176 W229TH ST FAIRVIEW PARK, OH 44126

204-26-056 5100 R 23717 KNICKERBOCKER RD 06/25/14 123,900 .590 Y 1
ALTHOFF, SUSAN WARRANTY D DOOLEY, LEIGH C & SIMMERLY, SUE L 40,800
651604 306819 Lnd: 32,800 Bld: 40,800 Tot: 73,600
ALTHOFF, SUSAN 23717 KNICKERBOCKER RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
ALTHOFF, SUSAN 23717 KNICKERBOCKER RD BAY VILLAGE, OH 44140
Total Number of Parcels: 64 Total Sales -10.00
Page 11